whos mad about tha clana breakup?? [Archive]

liana

03-30-2006, 07:41 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
I mad, but on this site, many will come running saying they are soooooo happy.

I can understand why you are mad. I'm not a clana fan, but I am mad as well. This is just not a reason for a breakup. Clark and Lana break up should be about both realizing they are not right for each other and they should part as best friends. Clana could have been a beautiful relationship if it had been written right. Unfortunately, many people became tired of the way writers waisted it.

I know you are clana fans, but please understand, I'm not against clana relationship per se, but I didn't like the way it has been written for a while. It should be treated with much more respect as it had been. What makes it worst is the fact that Lexana is coming, not as a beautiful relationship either, but as a mockery of everything Lana has been a long the years... That's one of the reasons I hope, as a clois fan, that Smallville writers never touch Clark and Lois relationship.

God-Man

03-30-2006, 07:42 PM

Originally posted by ferd
Umm..this is literally about the sixtieth time they've broken up. To be honest with you, I can't believe they're still beating this dead horse. They are not destined to be together, and after five years I think it's time to move on. For good.

hell yes.

ferd

03-30-2006, 07:43 PM

On a break. :lol: **has Friends flashbacks**

Dear God if they start splitting hairs like that I'm quite sure I'm going to have to start drinking before watching the show.

They did it respectfully at the end of Reckoning, but then they seem to have selective memory for their relationships.

They break up Clana with as much finality as they make Lex evil--it seldom sticks.

tmkfan

03-30-2006, 07:43 PM

[edited-Veaglarwen]

ferd

03-30-2006, 07:44 PM

[now irrelevent - offending post edited ~Veaglarwen]

Rafael122

03-30-2006, 07:45 PM

Yeah, I agree. Clana should end for good, but no Lexana.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:45 PM

Originally posted by liana
I can understand why you are mad. I'm not a clana fan, but I am mad as well. Clark and Lana break up should be about both realizing they are not right for each other and they should part as best friends. Clana could have been a beautiful relationship if it had been written right. Unfortunately, many people became tired of the way writers waisted it.

I know you are clana fans, but please understand, I'm not against clana relationship per se, but I didn't like the way it has been written for a while. It should be treated with much more respect as it had been. What makes it worst is the fact that Lexana is coming, not as a beautiful relationship either, but as a mockery of everything Lana has been a long the years... That's one of the reasons I hope, as a clois fan, that Smallville writers never touch Clark and Lois relationship.

Liana, you comfort me with your words. Clana should have been a beautiful relationship. It had the potential to be. And I agree that the writers shouldn't touch the Clois relationship; they can't seem to write a good one, besides Martha and Jonathan Kent.

Rafael122

03-30-2006, 07:46 PM

Originally posted by ferd
On a break. :lol: **has Friends flashbacks**

"WE WERE ON A BREAK!"

Patch123

03-30-2006, 07:47 PM

if lana n lex get together thats gunna suck ass.....

Kgatc13

03-30-2006, 07:48 PM

don't care...

jimmyolsenblues

03-30-2006, 07:48 PM

I have been mad at Lana since she left the Kent party win the wedding ring on to go comfort a drunken lex. So I don't mind a break because of the way lana has been written.

shaula luthor

03-30-2006, 07:49 PM

It´s time for moving on.......
This end is very welcome to me

wonderwomanS

03-30-2006, 07:49 PM

I am sad.. meanie clark! just tell Lana the 'dirty little secret' and everything will be okay :)

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:50 PM

I'm sad too. :( And mad. :mad:

ferd

03-30-2006, 07:50 PM

Originally posted by jimmyolsenblues
I have been mad at Lana since she left the Kent party win the wedding ring on to go comfort a drunken lex. So I don't mind a break because of the way lana has been written.

Word. That's not real evidence of someone so truly, deeply in love.

And can it be? The final sunset of the Clana?

Until next week when TPTB assume we all forgot...again. :\

djpnutz

03-30-2006, 07:50 PM

NOOOOOOOO

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:51 PM

Originally posted by jimmyolsenblues
I have been mad at Lana since she left the Kent party win the wedding ring on to go comfort a drunken lex. So I don't mind a break because of the way lana has been written.

What do you mean "comfort"? I see no problem with her answering a friend's call.

sstray72

03-30-2006, 07:51 PM

You're so freaking noble, Clark. :rolleyes:

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:52 PM

I agree. :rolleyes:

wonderwomanS

03-30-2006, 07:53 PM

"my feelings for you have changed!" WHAT the???

dude just tell her the secret! I am getting annoyed FOT (or whatever it is!) because he DOES LOVE HER!

shy175223

03-30-2006, 07:53 PM

yeah really noble!

shy175223

03-30-2006, 07:54 PM

really??

Rafael122

03-30-2006, 07:54 PM

Lana wants honesty, and she gets honesty. Now she's pissed. Women!

And now she acts like the one who broke it off. Unbelievable!

liana

03-30-2006, 07:54 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
Liana, you comfort me with your words. Clana should have been a beautiful relationship. It had the potential to be. And I agree that the writers shouldn't touch the Clois relationship; they can't seem to write a good one, besides Martha and Jonathan Kent.

You can always count on me for support where clana relationship is concerned. I consider the way it has been written as very disrespectful to all clana fans and superman fans as well. :(

ferd

03-30-2006, 07:54 PM

"I don't love you." :eek:

Bye bye sunset. Bye bye Lana.

*climbs off the rollercoaster and throws up*

Um, she's saying it's over?! Uh, he just said he didn't love her first. I think he has dibs on that break up.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:56 PM

Originally posted by liana
You can always count on me for support where clana relationship is concerned. I consider the way it has been written as very disrespectful to all clana fans and superman fans as well. :(

Thank you Liana. If it was Chloe, and that happened to her, Chlark fans would be hurt too. And we don't want TPTB coming near the Clois relationship.

Shy, I deleted that; I guess I lost my head for a minute.

shaula luthor

03-30-2006, 07:57 PM

Originally posted by wonderwomanS
I am sad.. meanie clark! just tell Lana the 'dirty little secret' and everything will be okay :)

I don´t see that way.
He did once and did you see what happened?

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:57 PM

She was on her way to dying the second time without knowing the secret.

ferd

03-30-2006, 07:58 PM

Well if it's any consolation, the Lexana is crushing my soul. :(

shy175223

03-30-2006, 07:58 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
Shy, I deleted that; I guess I lost my head for a minute.

Temporary insanity, huh?:)

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:59 PM

:lol:

redraven

03-30-2006, 07:59 PM

I don't care what any one else says I'm pissed. I've never hated an ending on Smallville quite like that one. He already caused her so much heart ache and all those years of her waiting and than he flat out says- I don't love you. Bull. Now Al and Miles are going to try and shove Lexana down our throats, sick.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 07:59 PM

Originally posted by ferd
Well if it's any consolation, the Lexana is crushing my soul. :(
I hear ya on that.

wonderwomanS

03-30-2006, 08:00 PM

yeah but Choloe (sp??) knows the 'dirty little secret' and so did that witch ...so why not tell someome that he loved! ???

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:01 PM

I hope the part about lana turn into the the woman scornes isn't true?

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:01 PM

Originally posted by redraven
I don't care what any one else says I'm pissed. I've never hated an ending on Smallville quite like that one. He already caused her so much heart ache and all those years of her waiting and than he flat out says- I don't love you. Bull. Now Al and Miles are going to try and shove Lexana down our throats, sick.

I agree. Their breakup should have been much mature (for lack of a better word).

Originally posted by shy175223
I hope the part about lana turn into the the woman scornes isn't true?

I agree.

redraven

03-30-2006, 08:02 PM

I think that the ultimate test of their love would be for him to tell her and see if she accepts him. And about the "she's not safe" thing, it is such a shallow and stupid reason for him not to tell her. People that hate Clark would go after Lana anyway because he loves her, she's in danger whether she knows his secret or not...so...I don't get it.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 08:02 PM

Stupid breakup. Just boiled down to the fact that Clark is a wimp who can't tell the truth. He could've at least told her the secret and then broke up with her, so she wasn't mad at him.

Erok-El

03-30-2006, 08:02 PM

My brother and I were jumping up and down with joy when Lana started to cry. I hate her with my whole heart. It is hard to type this through the laughter! Need to breathe...

ferd

03-30-2006, 08:02 PM

I'm glad we have a tiny common thread Cotton Candy girl. ;)

The Lexana IMHO is the source of all evil. I, personally would be happy to give the Dawson's Creek storylines a break, and get back to the bigger thing at hand: Clark becoming Superman, and Lex embracing his evil destiny.

midnite_spark

03-30-2006, 08:03 PM

so frustrated..i don't have any words....they're just messing up the whole storyline of superman!!

Patch123

03-30-2006, 08:03 PM

that makes me so mad clark should jus tell tha damn secret n everyone on that show needs to b writtin so their not all in clarks business.... but i know then there would b like now show... but still I really want lana to know that freakn secrett!!! ahhhh...

eas

03-30-2006, 08:04 PM

Oh that was just so sad and wrong on so many levels. He straight up lied to her -- that's the guy that's going to Superman?

I just don't understand how this boy is going to go on and have a real relationship with Lois Lane. In the real story, Lana is his friend.... and this is not how it should end.

Oh, I am sooooo disappointed right now. I agree -- I do not want them touching the Clois relationship... they'd just ruin it.

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:04 PM

Originally posted by Erok-El
My brother and I were jumping up and down with joy when Lana started to cry. I hate her with my whole heart. It is hard to type this through the laughter! Need to breathe...

you are are heartless.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:05 PM

Originally posted by ferd
I'm glad we have a tiny common thread Cotton Candy girl. ;)

The Lexana IMHO is the source of all evil. I, personally would be happy to give the Dawson's Creek storylines a break, and get back to the bigger thing at hand: Clark becoming Superman, and Lex embracing his evil destiny.

I agree, Ferd. What's this show really about anyway?

I know you hate Clana, and I understand your frustration with it actually. Maybe it's truly over now. I just want to see them be friends.

wonderwomanS

03-30-2006, 08:05 PM

hey looks like they will be friendly in the next episode!! :)

creampie

03-30-2006, 08:05 PM

i think my happiest memories of smallville are when clark and lana are together.. and HAPPY/DRAMA-FREE. sigh.. i'm in denial.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:05 PM

Thank God Clana is over! YAY!

thehenry89

03-30-2006, 08:05 PM

hahaha i could'nt be happier the final nail in the clana coffin i had to stop myself from summersaulting off the coach vive la vi la clois

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:07 PM

Yes, Clana's breakup had to come, but LIKE THIS? LIKE THIS? I mean geez, you didn't end it, you killed it and buried it, then drop a crap load of dirt in the grave, sealing the grave shut with metal latches and chains.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:07 PM

Viva la Lexana!!!

KryptonStones

03-30-2006, 08:07 PM

I feel like I've been waiting for this my entire life.

thehenry89

03-30-2006, 08:07 PM

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:07 PM

Cruelty, cruelty.

Nospam

03-30-2006, 08:07 PM

Originally posted by wonderwomanS
yeah but Choloe (sp??) knows the 'dirty little secret' and so did that witch ...so why not tell someome that he loved! ???

That's been my argument for a while now, that Clark has absolutely no reason not to tell Lana his secret. However, I think his mom made the point most eloquently that something else is behind Clark's decision, something he may not even be aware of. Maybe it's wishful thinking on her part, but it seems obvious to me that Martha has someone else in mind for Clark romantically.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:07 PM

A lot of people are happy that it's finally over. And *she* broke it off.

sstray72

03-30-2006, 08:08 PM

let the Jealous!Clark begin. Smallville will show how a nobody in the pantheon that is Superman Canon will cause Lex & Superman enmity.

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:08 PM

ALOOF! Don't rub it in, because know lexana is going to end too and i doubt it will be with Lana's heart broken.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:08 PM

Originally posted by Nospam
That's been my argument for a while now, that Clark has absolutely no reason not to tell Lana his secret.

You mean besides the fact that he supposedly loves her? Chloe even told him he should if he wanted to be in a relationship with her.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:08 PM

I'm not rubbing it in, I'm sharing my joy. :p

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:08 PM

Originally posted by thehenry89
hahaha i could'nt be happier the final nail in the clana coffin i had to stop myself from summersaulting off the coach vive la vi la clois

i wouldn't be jumping for joy if I were you. Do you really want Almiles to even touch Clois after this? I 'd think about that. and another Clana may not be over yet.

God-Man

03-30-2006, 08:08 PM

Originally posted by wonderwomanS
"my feelings for you have changed!" WHAT the???

dude just tell her the secret! I am getting annoyed FOT (or whatever it is!) because he DOES LOVE HER!

yup. It's clear that Clark still loves Lana deeply. I wanted him to eventually get over Lana, not force it like he did. Now we are going to see Clark mope around and get jealous of Lana's realtionship with Lex. The consolation is that this looks to be the LAST time they break up. I think TPTB realize that this needed to happen, that Clark and Lana had to break up.

Too bad. I loved seeing Clark and Lana happy together. hated it when they were angsting over each other.

Kriminal

03-30-2006, 08:09 PM

Clark even lied about how he feels about lana. hes a lieing machine.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 08:09 PM

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:09 PM

Originally posted by Kriminal
Clark even lied about how he feels about lana. hes a lieing machine.

Ehhhh, so is Lex. That's why it's so scandalous!

ferd

03-30-2006, 08:09 PM

She broke it off??

Did he not say 'I don't love you' first?

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:10 PM

Yes, but SHE said it was over.

shirkie

03-30-2006, 08:10 PM

It's over, it's over, it's over! The night has ended, the morning has dawned, the rain has stopped, the sun has come out, the Meteor the Stompy Horse of Relationships has come and trampled, trampled, trampled that foul creature known as Clana and my heart soars!

Err... I mean, erm, I'm pleased with this latest plot development.
shirkie

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:10 PM

Originally posted by Kriminal
Clark even lied about how he feels about lana. hes a lieing machine.
Some needed laughter for me. Thanks....lying machine, lol.

Kriminal

03-30-2006, 08:10 PM

if clark didnt really think she was the one then why did he tell her the first time around.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:11 PM

He caused her too much pain, it was destined to happen!

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:11 PM

That's been my argument for a while now, that Clark has absolutely no reason not to tell Lana his secret. However, I think his mom made the point most eloquently that something else is behind Clark's decision, something he may not even be aware of. Maybe it's wishful thinking on her part, but it seems obvious to me that Martha has someone else in mind for Clark romantically.

He loves her, why wouldn't he want to tell her? Why wouldn't he want to be happy? There's so many reason clark has to tell Lana. I thought what Martha said was off and bad imo. I mean i expected more comforting that.

I'm not rubbing it in, I'm sharing my joy.

Do you have no heart?:p

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:12 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
I mean, erm, I'm pleased with this latest plot development.
shirkie
You mean until the next time they get back together?

I think I'm even getting tired of the merry-go-round.

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:12 PM

He caused her too much pain, it was destined to happen!

Just like the end of lexana will be destined to happen.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:12 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
He caused her too much pain, it was destined to happen!
Think about it... you think Lex won't?

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:13 PM

Originally posted by Kriminal
if clark didnt really think she was the one then why did he tell her the first time around.

umm.. good point.

thehenry89

03-30-2006, 08:13 PM

Originally posted by shy175223
i wouldn't be jumping for joy if I were you. Do you really want Almiles to even touch Clois after this? I 'd think about that. and another Clana may not be over yet.

the can hint at it but i don't think they should put it full out on the show

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:13 PM

Think about it... you think Lex won't?

Nope, because she doesn't love Lex like that. There's no way he could.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:14 PM

Originally posted by myankskent
They basically created a stupid way for Lexana to start. Clark lied to her, he does love her but fears for her safety and doesn't want to keep hurting her. There is no grand revelation there. He ended it to protect her, but because he is a coward, he made Lana hate his guts and I can't fault Lana for feeling that way.

Word.

boogalou86

03-30-2006, 08:14 PM

Me...i'm mad at the Clana breakup...

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:14 PM

Yes, but most of us Lexana fans are thrilled if we even get one Lexana scene. This is like gold for us, it doesn't matter how it ends, as long as it happens! :D

The Great Ymmij

03-30-2006, 08:14 PM

As a Clana fan, that really sucked bad. I'm not looking forward to Lexana.... But Lexana fans rejoice cuz this is the birth of it.

Kriminal

03-30-2006, 08:14 PM

I knew that they were going to break up but i didnt like how they did it. That was really lame.

ferd

03-30-2006, 08:14 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
Yes, but SHE said it was over.

If someone tells me they don't love me, I'm not sticking around enough to say it's over. They already said it pretty darn loud and clear. I'd catch the clue and go home and eat some ice cream. But I'm smart. ;) :p

sheltiemom

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

How was singing Hallelujah. Glad it's over, now I can only pray it stays that way!! And of course my first conscience thought- why couldn't he do this before Reckoning-- and for this Jonathan had to die.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

Originally posted by SmallvilleMan
Nope, because she doesn't love Lex like that. There's no way he could.

I agree, but I guess I'm saying he'll probably try.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

It grew old after the first 3 times they hooked up. Three strikes you're out!

myankskent

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

Oh this Lexana thing is going to be used for Clark's jealousy, that's it. It's a device just like kryptonite. It will be used for the rest of this season so Clark can second guess his decision. Then all hell will break loose in the finale and we won't know who will be with who by the time season 6 begins. Once again, it is a clever, or stupid, depending on how you look at it, way to rip off about a billion soap operas out there.

ferd

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

I don't embrace the Lexana, but more Lex is never a bad thing. I can just hold my hand up over half the screen. ;) :lol:

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

Originally posted by ferd
If someone tells me they don't love me, I'm not sticking around enough to say it's over. They already said it pretty darn loud and clear. I'd catch the clue and go home and eat some ice cream. But I'm smart. ;) :p

Word.

Freemind

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

I hate Lois. If they do something with her and Clark... Ahhh, I hate Lois. Do something with Clark and Chloe now that Lana is out of the picture. Lex and Lana go good like Chloe and Clark. Kill off Lois. I know it doesn't follow the comics but god, do you have to be so picky about everything in the comics.

sefi

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

Not mad at the Clana breakup. Very happy that it has come finally. And I hope that this break up sticks.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:15 PM

I hope Clark moves on, he should just GROW UP.

KEakaCK

03-30-2006, 08:16 PM

I'm not mad...The whole Lana and Clark thing where he gets her mad or upset then apologize over and over got really old...

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:17 PM

Originally posted by Freemind
I hate Lois. If they do something with her and Clark... Ahhh, I hate Lois. Do something with Clark and Chloe now that Lana is out of the picture. Lex and Lana go good like Chloe and Clark. Kill off Lois. I know it doesn't follow the comics but god, do you have to be so picky about everything in the comics.

they shoudn't even touch Chlark!

myankskent

03-30-2006, 08:17 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
Yes, but most of us Lexana fans are thrilled if we even get one Lexana scene. This is like gold for us, it doesn't matter how it ends, as long as it happens! :D

Well then you obviously don't care about the integrity of the show or about the superman mythology. It's ok if you don't but some of us don't want to watch a soap opera here. Storylines like this will drive away most of the viewers out there, and then you won't be able to watch your precious Lexana scenes because the show will be off the air as a result of declining ratings.

shirkie

03-30-2006, 08:17 PM

They are NOT going to get back together. Did anyone see how PISSED Lana is? She is finally going to grow a backbone and not put up with any more of his crap (and I hope that was the last time she uses the phrase "secrets and lies"). Lana is going to turn out to be a little hellfire... And it's going to be interesting. A lot more interesting than the damn Clana-go-round.
shirkie

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:17 PM

Hey, you get to see more of Lex, which is never a bad thing! :D

Erok-El

03-30-2006, 08:18 PM

Originally posted by thehenry89
the can hint at it but i don't think they should put it full out on the show

I have to disagree with you there. I think they should have Clois on the show. The story is so vastly different than the comics it would just be another difference.

Bring on the Clois!!!

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:18 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
They are NOT going to get back together. Did anyone see how PISSED Lana is? She is finally going to grow a backbone and not put up with any more of his crap (and I hope that was the last time she uses the phrase "secrets and lies"). Lana is going to turn out to be a little hellfire... And it's going to be interesting. A lot more interesting than the damn Clana-go-round.
shirkie

Totally! ;) Lexana makes things for interesting, it means Lana is turning dark.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:19 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
They are NOT going to get back together. Did anyone see how PISSED Lana is? She is finally going to grow a backbone and not put up with any more of his crap (and I hope that was the last time she uses the phrase "secrets and lies"). Lana is going to turn out to be a little hellfire... And it's going to be interesting. A lot more interesting than the damn Clana-go-round.
shirkie

Well actually Shirkie, I think we have found a little bit of common ground.

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:19 PM

Originally posted by Erok-El
I have to disagree with you there. I think they should have Clois on the show. The story is so vastly different than the comics it would just be another difference.

Bring on the Clois!!!

forget that they might messed that one up that way, too.

sstray72

03-30-2006, 08:19 PM

Originally posted by Nospam
That's been my argument for a while now, that Clark has absolutely no reason not to tell Lana his secret.

Clark had legitamate reasons for not telling Lana before Wreckoning.

-Lana's pankaked parents
-Lana's hatred of the meteor shower (before season 5 when she mysteriously developed an interest and expertise in astronomy.)
-Lana's feelings toward extraterrestrials: "freaked out" (2-18 Visitor)
-Lana's dislike, maybe even hatred towards meteor freaks due to her repeated encounters with them(3-3 Extinction), who's origin can be blamed on Clark

All of these reasons for not telling her the secret somehow became replaced with her being in danger in "Retconning," because Lana somehow became okay with Clark being an extraterrestrial who's appearance coincided with her parent's death and created stalking murderous meteor freaks. :rolleyes:

Nospam

03-30-2006, 08:20 PM

Originally posted by Kriminal
Clark even lied about how he feels about lana. hes a lieing machine.

I don't think he was lying. Something tells me he doesn't feel the same way about Lana. His mom even made the point, perhaps out of wishful thinking, that Lana may not be the one and Clark didn't deny it. I think it's beginning to dawn on him, heavens be praised, that there are others girls out there.

We'll see in coming episodes how Clark deals with it, namely Fade. If they play up the forlorn Clark till the end of the season I am going to throw a shoe at the TV. Now that Clana is officially over let it die a dignified death so we can move on.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:20 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
it means Lana is turning dark.

Slow your roll a little bit. :p; I hope she doesn't turn dark after 4.5 seasons....grrrrr.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:20 PM

This is Lex, he's an evil mastermind with the hots for Lana, but can he see why kids love the sweet cinnamon taste of cinnamon toast crunch cereal?

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:20 PM

They basically created a stupid way for Lexana to start. Clark lied to her, he does love her but fears for her safety and doesn't want to keep hurting her. There is no grand revelation there. He ended it to protect her, but because he is a coward, he made Lana hate his guts and I can't fault Lana for feeling that way.

I don't get this Lana hating him thing. Why is she going to hate him? I mean be angry with him i understand or maybe disliking him. However, hating him? This is a guy who has saved her life so many times and a guy she loves. Now she's going to hate him? Huh?

KEakaCK

03-30-2006, 08:21 PM

I wouldn't be surprised with this version of the story has Lois finding out the truth about Clark and fall in love with each other before they even move to Metropolis...I wouldn't put it pass the writers.

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:21 PM

Originally posted by KEakaCK
I wouldn't be surprised with this version of the story has Lois finding out the truth about Clark and fall in love with each other before they even move to Metropolis...I wouldn't put it pass the writers.

yeah, and than she gets her memory erased.

Nospam

03-30-2006, 08:22 PM

Originally posted by sstray72
Clark had legitamate reasons for not telling Lana before Wreckoning.

-Lana's pankaked parents
-Lana's hatred of the meteor shower (before season 5 when she mysteriously developed an interest and expertise in astronomy.)
-Lana's feelings toward extraterrestrials: "freaked out" (2-18 Visitor)
-Lana's dislike, maybe even hatred towards meteor freaks due to her repeated encounters with them(3-3 Extinction), who's origin can be blamed on Clark

All of these reasons for not telling her the secret somehow became replaced with her being in danger in "Retconning," because Lana somehow became okay[/] with Clark being an extraterrestrial who's appearance coincided with her parent's death and created stalking murderous meteor freaks. :rolleyes:

All of that is nullified by the reaction we saw of Lana in Reckoning. She loved and accepted him as an alien. End of story.

My premise still holds.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:22 PM

I don't know why Lana would Clark, though.

sstray72

03-30-2006, 08:22 PM

Originally posted by KryptonStones
I feel like I've been waiting for this my entire life.

You're very articulate and a great typer for a 4 and a half year old... :lol:

thehenry89

03-30-2006, 08:22 PM

Originally posted by Erok-El
I have to disagree with you there. I think they should have Clois on the show. The story is so vastly different than the comics it would just be another difference.

Bring on the Clois!!!

yeah but i'd just be so pissed if the put it on the show and then messed it up you know what i mean.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:23 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
can he see why kids love the sweet cinnamon taste of cinnamon toast crunch cereal?

What? :lol:

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:23 PM

I think Lex looked a little guilty at the very end...

shirkie

03-30-2006, 08:23 PM

I think it's stupid that the last episode-- "Cyborg"-- had Clark telling Lana he loved her and will always love her. And then this week came along and was like "La la la, I forgot what I just said..."

Off-topic, but who else thought Breakup!Lana's hair was adorable?
shirkie

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:23 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
What? :lol:

Just trying to lighten the mood! :p

liana

03-30-2006, 08:24 PM

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:24 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
I think it's stupid that the last episode-- "Cyborg"-- had Clark telling Lana he loved her and will always love her. And then this week came along and was like "La la la, I forgot what I just said..."

Off-topic, but who else thought Breakup!Lana's hair was adorable?
shirkie

I love it! I have long brown hair like her, maybe I can do that! Or maybe not. :\

MBCorp

03-30-2006, 08:25 PM

I hate this entire relationship plot. All of it. Clana breaking up doesn't even bring me any joy because of the stupid way that they've went about it. Plus, oh horrors, the Lexana. And a rage filled Lana. God.

Anyway, I agree Shirkie, Lana's hair was really cute in that scene!

amberdawn

03-30-2006, 08:25 PM

Originally posted by liana
As a clois fan I am going to speak loud and clear: Don't ever touch clois relationship, Smallville writers. I love Lois Lane character, and I already think they have tainted her enough in this show. If they ever dare to touch clois relationship... I said once and I will say it again: You have all the right to be angry now, clana fans. :mad: :mad: :mad: And I am sorry for what they have been doing to your ship over the years. I know some of you may think they are doing this because in the Comics Lana and Clark are not together, but I think the real reason is because they love triangle and they have been wanting to play Lex/Lana/Clark since day one... :\ :\ :\ :\
I completely agree. And I actually felt bad for Lana in this episode. What a way to kick her in the teeth.

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:25 PM

Now that Clana is officially over let it die a dignified death so we can move on.

hahaaha, dignified? Dignified? How can it be dignified after this episode? HOW? First off, Clark denies loving her, everyone says Lana is going to hate clark, martha says Clark doesn't think Lana is the one. Dignified? I know the breakup had to happen, but what is so bad about this kind of breakup:

Clark: Lana as much as I love you, we can't be together anymore. I know you don't understand, but I can't be hones with you and i can't keep hurting you like this.

What's so hard about him saying that or letting him say that? They destroyed clana into dust, then took a crap on it.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 08:26 PM

Originally posted by SmallvilleMan
I don't get this Lana hating him thing. Why is she going to hate him? I mean be angry with him i understand or maybe disliking him. However, hating him? This is a guy who has saved her life so many times and a guy she loves. Now she's going to hate him? Huh?

Maybe hate is strong but she sees that all he has done is dragged her through the mud. This won't make her want to hang out with him anytime soon. Clark may have saved her life in the past, but this is the present. Clark was a fool to end it in that way. It's just like what Chloe told him, if he ended it then Lana and him would never be the same again. Clark took the easy way out, he decided not to tell her the truth because it was too hard on him so he lied to her face and said it was over. You can tell that he was lying when he said that he didn't love her. Now what he could've done is told her the secret, and then broke up with her. Lana would understand more if that happened and wouldn't hate him. If anything, she would see that he is being responsible in breaking up with her. But instead, Clark does something unsuperman-like and lies through his teeth to make it better for himself.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:26 PM

rightwing

03-30-2006, 08:27 PM

I am with you.

This is not the way it should be done. What a mistake (if this is truly the way the writers are going). To have Lana brokenhearted and now have the possibilty of her doing something terribly wrong (and out of character) because of it is just not right.

Whether the people on this board want to admit it or not. Smallville is a success because of the presence of beautiful Kristen Kreuk as Lana and the pure emotion and chemistry of the two characters Clark and Lana. To have it end in such a manner would spell disaster for this show now and in the future (I mean who would ever be able to watch the innocence of these two shattered by the animosity that will come later?

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:28 PM

Originally posted by SmallvilleMan
hahaaha, dignified? Dignified? How can it be dignified after this episode? HOW? First off, Clark denies loving her, everyone says Lana is going to hate clark, martha says Clark doesn't think Lana is the one. Dignified? I know the breakup had to happen, but what is so bad about this kind of breakup:

Clark: Lana as much as I love you, we can't be together anymore. I know you don't understand, but I can't be hones with you and i can't keep hurting you like this.

What's so hard about him saying that or letting him say that? They destroyed clana into dust.

That's my point. I would prefer a dignified breakup. I'm so disappointed in TPTB.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:29 PM

I think that's the point. To destroy Clana! :p

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 08:29 PM

As a clois fan I am going to speak loud and clear: Don't ever touch clois relationship, Smallville writers. I love Lois Lane character, and I already think they have tainted her enough in this show. If they ever dare to touch clois relationship... I said once and I will say it again: You have all the right to be angry now, clana fans. And I am sorry for what they have been doing to your ship over the years. I know some of you may think they are doing this because in the Comics Lana and Clark are not together, but I think the real reason is because they love triangle and they have been wanting to play Lex/Lana/Clark since day one...

Yes, i would feel bad for you if they touched clois.

Maybe hate is strong but she sees that all he has done is dragged her through the mud. This won't make her want to hang out with him anytime soon. Clark may have saved her life in the past, but this is the present. Clark was a fool to end it in that way. It's just like what Chloe told him, if he ended it then Lana and him would never be the same again. Clark took the easy way out, he decided not to tell her the truth because it was too hard on him so he lied to her face and said it was over. You can tell that he was lying when he said that he didn't love her. Now what he could've done is told her the secret, and then broke up with her. Lana would understand more if that happened and wouldn't hate him. If anything, she would see that he is being responsible in breaking up with her. But instead, Clark does something unsuperman-like and lies through his teeth to make it better for himself.

Off course he was lying and being a coward. She still shouldn't hate her, i don't when he saved her, when you save someone's life as many times as Clark has, you shouldnt hate that person ever.

shy175223

03-30-2006, 08:30 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
That's my point. I would prefer a dignified breakup; I'm so disappointed in TPTB.

Me. too. Something along the lines that they were'nt right for each other afterall along with Clark actually telling Lana the truth. That would have be something.

shirkie

03-30-2006, 08:31 PM

Oh for crying out loud. "Smallville" is a success ONLY because of KK and KK's "chemistry" with TW? PLEASE don't turn this into a thread about THAT. The Clana turned "Smallville" into a freaking soap opera-- this breakup will rejuvenate the show.
shirkie

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:31 PM

Yeah, it should have been. I do feel bad for Lana, she was really upset, and that did make me sad.

eas

03-30-2006, 08:31 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
Well said.

I have to agree... I'm feeling your pain, Clana fans. I'm, personally, all about Clois -- but after this episode I feel really bad for y'all.

What they're doing to your ship sucks. They should have more respect for the fans that stuck through this for years and waited patiently for them to get together. To end it like this is disrespectful to everybody - the characters and the fans.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 08:31 PM

Originally posted by SmallvilleMan

Off course he was lying and being a coward. She still shouldn't hate her, i don't when he saved her, when you save someone's life as many times as Clark has, you shouldnt hate that person ever.

If Al/Miles want her to hate him, then she'll hate him. They don't care if it doesn't make sense, they want to do what they want to do and they will make it as unrealistic as possible to get the job done.

amberdawn

03-30-2006, 08:32 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
That's my point. I would prefer a dignified breakup.
Absolutely. I really felt bad for Lana and never wanted them to break up this way. I would of rather had it mutual between Lana and Clark.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 08:33 PM

Originally posted by eas
I have to agree... I'm feeling your pain, Clana fans. I'm, personally, all about Clois -- but after this episode I feel really bad for y'all.

What they're doing to your ship sucks. They should have more respect for the fans that stuck through this for years and waited patiently for them to get together. To end it like this is disrespectful to everybody - the characters and the fans.

That's so eloquently said; it actually makes me want to cry. We have waited (although I haven't been around for 5 years like some), and now they break them up like this?

myankskent

03-30-2006, 08:34 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
Oh for crying out loud. "Smallville" is a success ONLY because of KK and KK's "chemistry" with TW? PLEASE don't turn this into a thread about THAT. The Clana turned "Smallville" into a freaking soap opera-- this breakup will rejuvenate the show.
shirkie

Hello? Do you know what a soap opera is? Going from one relationship to the next is what it is. In this case, we go from Clana to Lexana in about 2 episodes. Then we go from Clana to potentially Chlark after that. THAT is what a soap opera is. So this Clana breakup has basically given us bigger, more nauseating soap opera-style storylines.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:35 PM

They're going to make Lexana fans swoon like crazy! :p Lana is going to be one rich girl, lol.

rightwing

03-30-2006, 08:35 PM

Uhhh Shirkie. Your arrogance knows no bounds.

shirkie

03-30-2006, 08:37 PM

But Lana isn't "supposed" to end up with Lex... She's "supposed" to end up with Pete. Right? I mean, that's obviously not going to happen anytime in the near future, what with Pete being in Wichita and all (anyone else appreciate the reference to Aunt Nell, who we've now confirmed has not disappeared off the face of the earth), but Lex and Lana don't stay together overall.
shirkie

OutlawAngel

03-30-2006, 08:37 PM

Originally posted by Rafael122
They broke up again? Jeez, this is going on Ross and Rachel territory.

Usually I find the one again off again then on again while being off again but really being on again till they are off again relationship is hilarious to me. But Lana and Clark broke my heart tonight. Kristin was amazing. I am gonna say that IMO that this was the best acting Kristin ever has shown. I was near tears when she ran out of the barn after catching Simone and Clark together.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:38 PM

Originally posted by OutlawAngel
Usually I find the one again off again then on again while being off again but really being on again till they are off again relationship is hilarious to me. But Lana and Clark broke my heart tonight. Kristin was amazing. I am gonna say that IMO that this was the best acting Kristin ever has shown. I was near tears when she ran out of the barn after catching Simone and Clark together.

Yeah! I was going to say, her acting has improved greatly! :D

sstray72

03-30-2006, 08:38 PM

Chlana = ratings.

amberdawn

03-30-2006, 08:38 PM

She did a great job tonight. I felt her pain, I really did.

shirkie

03-30-2006, 08:39 PM

Even I thought KK was spectacular tonight. Eek, am I high on breakup joy? No, she really was wonderful.
shirkie

thehenry89

03-30-2006, 08:40 PM

Originally posted by sstray72
Chlana = ratings.

fo sho

Aloof

03-30-2006, 08:42 PM

In your dreams DUDES. ;)

janedoe

03-30-2006, 08:42 PM

This breakup was so contrived, I hated it, I just hope its not season 4 all over again.

OutlawAngel

03-30-2006, 08:47 PM

Originally posted by ferd
Word. That's not real evidence of someone so truly, deeply in love.

And can it be? The final sunset of the Clana?

Until next week when TPTB assume we all forgot...again. :\

Speaking of which that is the first time it seems in awhile that we have seen one of them CGI sunsets. Could that of been a cool lil tie in like in Reckoning when Clark had blood on his hands only this time the sunset would be like showing this really is the end for the 2?

Kal-Elder

03-30-2006, 08:55 PM

Okay...I'll be the first to say it..

knowing AlMiles, I just don't think we have seen the last of Clana...
I can not count the times that I have thought or read that this is the end..no really this time..wait...ok, now this time for real.

I think that with all of a season 6 to go that it is just impossible for me to think that there will be no more Clana, not with the way the show has been written in the past.

Ahh well just my opinion, nobody blow a gasket and scream that it is over for real...for really real this time, cause I just have a hard time trusting anything TPTB say.I guess time will tell...

I still hold to my original argument, as long as there is Smallville, there will be Clana.

Frindship/Clana
Romantic/Clana
Hate/Clana
Jealous/Clana
Stalker/Clana (lord help us)
Hopeyourhitbyabus/Clana
HopeLexanaishitbyabus/Clana

on
and on
and on...

Nospam

03-30-2006, 08:58 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
Even I thought KK was spectacular tonight. Eek, am I high on breakup joy? No, she really was wonderful.
shirkie

I think it was the first time I actually believed her tears were those of sadness and not something from the Acting for Dummies book.

She was good and I was caught off guard when she ended it with the punctuated, "forever".

kryptohag

03-30-2006, 09:01 PM

Hmmm... I can't decided if I'm pissed or glad that they broke it off. Actually, I think I feel both. I'm mad that this happened, because I love watching the Kristom chemistry, and I also am happy that this whole damn drama is finally over. I really did not enjoy how the writers portrayed the clana relationship. They had more drama happening in their relationship then all the soap opreas combined.

Watching Lana cry (outside the barn) like that was heart wrenching. I can feel her pain. :( (BTW: If you watch real carefully you can see KK drool, hehe. That was funny.)

After watching the episode, I could not believe that the writers wrote off their relationship like that. They shouldn't have had Clark tell Lana that he doesn't love her. WHY?? The writers could at least end it in a way where Clark and Lana both realize they can't be doing what their doing anymore and just be friends. Why couldn't it happen like that? I guess this doesn't make for a good show. Ah, the drama!

*SPOILER*
Also... Why would anyone (KK, the writers, producers, DC Comics, etc) agree to have Lana become a druggy in the next episode. What kind of message is this going to send to her younger fans and the viewers? Is KK's character actually that weak to do something so irresponsible and unLana-like?

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 09:05 PM

Originally posted by Kal-Elder
Okay...I'll be the first to say it..

knowing AlMiles, I just don't think we have seen the last of Clana...
I can not count the times that I have thought or read that this is the end..no really this time..wait...ok, now this time for real.

I think that with all of a season 6 to go that it is just impossible for me to think that there will be no more Clana, not with the way the show has been written in the past.

Ahh well just my opinion, nobody blow a gasket and scream that it is over for real...for really real this time, cause I just have a hard time trusting anything TPTB say.I guess time will tell...

I still hold to my original argument, as long as there is Smallville, there will be Clana.

Frindship/Clana
Romantic/Clana
Hate/Clana
Jealous/Clana
Stalker/Clana (lord help us)
Hopeyourhitbyabus/Clana
HopeLexanaishitbyabus/Clana

on
and on
and on...

That's what I've been saying, but I guess since I'm a Clana fan, for some people it has less credence when I say it.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 09:07 PM

Originally posted by kryptohag
Hmmm... I can't decided if I'm pissed or glad that they broke it off. Actually, I think I feel both. I'm mad that this happened, because I love watching the Kristom chemistry, and I also am happy that this whole damn drama is finally over. I really did not enjoy how the writers portrayed the clana relationship. They had more drama happening in their relationship then all the soap opreas combined.

Watching Lana cry (outside the barn) like that was heart wrenching. I can feel her pain. :( (BTW: If you watch real carefully you can see KK drool, hehe. That was funny.)

After watching the episode, I could not believe that the writers wrote off their relationship like that. They shouldn't have had Clark tell Lana that he doesn't love her. WHY?? The writers could at least end it in a way where Clark and Lana both realize they can't be doing what their doing anymore and just be friends. Why couldn't it happen like that? I guess this doesn't make for a good show. Ah, the drama!

*SPOILER*
Also... Why would anyone (KK, the writers, producers, DC Comics, etc) agree to have Lana become a druggy in the next episode. What kind of message is this going to send to her younger fans and the viewers? Is KK's character actually that weak to do something so irresponsible and unLana-like?

Well it's probably Lex that is doing it to her. Wasn't she strapped down or something being injected with it? That sounds like Lex to me.

shirkie

03-30-2006, 09:09 PM

No she becomes a krypto-junkie... Stuff to make her be able to contact her Pancaked!Parents is addictive. Poor thang. :(
shirkie

JD_lover5943

03-30-2006, 09:10 PM

I hate Clana, but during half the episode I was yelling at the TV telling Clark to just get over himself and tell her his secret so they can finally be together for good.

OutlawAngel

03-30-2006, 09:12 PM

Originally posted by Kriminal
I knew that they were going to break up but i didnt like how they did it. That was really lame.

I hated the way they broke up too and I aint even a Clana fan so I cant even imagine how all yall Clana fans must feel.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:12 PM

im afraid this was the last time we ever really will see romantic clana. It sucks because they ended o9n such bad terms and i think there was so much foreshadowing in this episode that clark and lana are broken up for good. Chloe says that this is it if clark breaks up with her now its over, done, finished, he can not be with her ever again. Also Ma kent says that maybe lana wasnt really the girl clark pictured spending the rest of his life with. im really pissed i think it was a horrible episode. Not like any action and had the same villian as in season 2 episode 2 "Heat" where the girl had superspeed hormones and could get anybody to do what she wanted. i hate that clana romantic ends this way, i really wanted to see them happy for at least one episode where lana remembers clark's secret and they have no angst and all of that. i was wishing for in the 6th season they could be happy for soime episodes before lana finds out clark's destiny and jor-el and lets him go off to train and do better things in the world. i can still hope for that But for all of us clana fans im sad to say im pretty sure its over for good after seeing all the foreshadowing in this episode. Also iof we get dark-lana words cannot express how pissed i will be. That line martha kent said at the end, "lets hope this doesnt drive lana to do something we will all regret." scares the hell out of me. If we get dark-lana i can honestly say i will be very tempted to stop watching smallville.

thehenry89

03-30-2006, 09:12 PM

Originally posted by myankskent
Well it's probably Lex that is doing it to her. Wasn't she strapped down or something being injected with it? That sounds like Lex to me.

rowr bondage lexana now thats worth the price of admisson and more.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 09:17 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
No she becomes a krypto-junkie... Stuff to make her be able to contact her Pancaked!Parents is addictive. Poor thang. :(
shirkie

And where do you think she gets the serum? At the local cvs store or from Lex's Luthorcorp?

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:17 PM

They really failed on breaking up Clana sucessfully. They didn't leave it a shred of dignity and Clark came off more as a jerk than a noble anything. Who breaks up with someone to avoid hurting them by hurting them again? It doesn't make sense. And if Clark had an intelligent brain anywhere in that skull, he should know that Lex has far more potential to bring her pain.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:18 PM

I don't think Lex would do that to her. What would be the purpose?

Erok-El

03-30-2006, 09:18 PM

Originally posted by thehenry89
rowr bondage lexana now thats worth the price of admisson and more.

I would pay to see that, I am serious!

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 09:19 PM

Originally posted by muffinpeddler
They really failed on breaking up Clana sucessfully. They didn't leave it a shred of dignity and Clark came off more as a jerk than a noble anything. Who breaks up with someone to avoid hurting them by hurting them again? It doesn't make sense. And if Clark had an intelligent brain anywhere in that skull, he should know that Lex has far more potential to bring her pain.

I'm so glad so many people see it. What a rip-off. Even a lot of non-Clana fans agree.

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:19 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
No she becomes a krypto-junkie... Stuff to make her be able to contact her Pancaked!Parents is addictive. Poor thang. :(
shirkie

So she's STILL traumatized by their loss? Geesh, I can't even remember anything from when I was three. I thought she got over that a season or two ago. looks like filler episode.

Kal-Elder

03-30-2006, 09:19 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
That's what I've been saying, but I guess since I'm a Clana fan, for some people it has less credence when I say it.

I think you have lots of credence girl:D

And don't get me wrong I like Clana too...but I just feel like TPTB have done the bait and switch...

They have shown us that, OK, we know that we have told you this time it is over again and again..but this time we really mean it..Clark said it was over, Chloe said it was over, Lana said it was over, heck the freakin sun even set in the back ground for cryin out loud.
But I think that was all a set up so Lana can be mad at Clark and hookup with Lex (shiver) and then she will treat him bad,so all can be patched up in season 6..

I guess I just remember AlMiles sayin that the end of Clana will be bittersweet, and there was noting sweet about the end tonight, man, I thought she was gonna gouge his eyes out with a fork :rotfl:

Like I said just a theory and speculation...guess maybe that is where I should post it:lol: :lol:

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:20 PM

I'm a non-Clana fan, and I think it was pretty mean as well.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:21 PM

Originally posted by Patch123
yeaa um im really pissed about tha clana breakup?? i mean all this time trying to get there relashinship together n then it jus stops?? what tha hell??? whos with me??

i think just about every fan no matter what ship you support is angry about this break up (except lexana fans). The writers did it poorly and not in class at all, Having clark tell her he didnt love her sucked. Im sure no matter what ship you support you didnt wanna see them end it on these terms. All i can do is try to get through the lexana scenes in the following episodes with a barf bag, and just hope that lexana is done with by the season finale and lana knows clark's secret.

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:21 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
I don't think Lex would do that to her. What would be the purpose?

Not on purpose, just by his nature. He'll begin to treat Lana as more of an asset or posession than a lover, and he's only telling her truths now because she saw the ship. He still lies to her.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 09:21 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
I don't think Lex would do that to her. What would be the purpose?

If she was a key to giving him the answers that he wants, no matter what it is, he would hurt her. I think that he is the one that provides Lana with the serum next week. Maybe he wants Lana to go back and see if she can find out something that could help him with the ship. So if he does have a part in the serum, are you actually going to tell me that he doesn't want to hurt her? If he didn't want to hurt her then he wouldn't give her the serum in the first place.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:22 PM

Maybe he's tricking her! :eek: He gives her the serum and then tries to help her. Woha. :eek:

And who says it wouldn't be twisted? ;)

myankskent

03-30-2006, 09:23 PM

Originally posted by jason127
i think just about every fan no matter what ship you support is angry about this break up (except lexana fans). The writers did it poorly and not in class at all, Having clark tell her he didnt love her sucked. Im sure no matter what ship you support you didnt wanna see them end it on these terms. All i can do is try to get through the lexana scenes in the following episodes with a barf bag, and just hope that lexana is done with by the season finale and lana knows clark's secret.

It'll be shortlived. There's no way that Lex can have a relationship with a girl last. He always messes up at some point.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:24 PM

Originally posted by muffinpeddler
Not on purpose, just by his nature. He'll begin to treat Lana as more of an asset or posession than a lover, and he's only telling her truths now because she saw the ship. He still lies to her.

totally agree the only thing lex has to offer lana is the same as clark, secrets and lies.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:24 PM

Like I said before, it's like gold for Lexana fans. We don't wanna know NOTHING!

ferd

03-30-2006, 09:24 PM

Who wants to put down money on how long it takes for Lana to start sporting diamond earrings? ;) :lol:

myankskent

03-30-2006, 09:24 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
Maybe he's tricking her! :eek: He gives her the serum and then tries to help her. Woha. :eek:

And who says it wouldn't be twisted? ;)

Point is if it's twisted then Lex really doesn't care about Lana. I don't want to hear people shout that they are both meant for each other when Lex is putting Lana in danger to get what he wants. Come on now.

Clark is a moron, but at least he never puts Lana in danger. He just gives her emotional pain. Lex will give her physical pain if it means finding out what he wants.

Welling Is Hot

03-30-2006, 09:24 PM

I think the writers owed a little more to their fans than ending it this way there is a clear 40-40 split between pro and anti clana fans and 20 percent neutral they couldn't find a happy medium somewhere they had to do it the lazy way with some FOTW induced garbage?

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:24 PM

That's mean! :mad:

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 09:24 PM

Originally posted by Kal-Elder
I think you have lots of credence girl:D

And don't get me wrong I like Clana too...but I just feel like TPTB have done the bait and switch...

They have shown us that, OK, we know that we have told you this time it is over again and again..but this time we really mean it..Clark said it was over, Chloe said it was over, Lana said it was over, heck the freakin sun even set in the back ground for cryin out loud.
But I think that was all a set up so Lana can be mad at Clark and hookup with Lex (shiver) and then she will treat him bad,so all can be patched up in season 6..

I guess I just remember AlMiles sayin that the end of Clana will be bittersweet, and there was noting sweet about the end tonight, man, I thought she was gonna gouge his eyes out with a fork :rotfl:

Like I said just a theory and speculation...guess maybe that is where I should post it:lol: :lol:

Thanks. :)

I agree with you. I've been on a rollercoaster ride with this relationship. And I think you're right; they had to do something like this so Lex and Lana would get into a relationship. I don't think she would otherwise.

And I still hope I get my bittersweet ending somewhere down the line. :mad:

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:25 PM

Originally posted by myankskent
Point is if it's twisted then Lex really doesn't care about Lana. I don't want to hear people shout that they are both meant for each other when Lex is putting Lana in danger to get what he wants. Come on now.

Hey, it's my favorite ship. I don't care what happens, it's sick and twisted and dark. IMO of course.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:25 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
Maybe he's tricking her! :eek: He gives her the serum and then tries to help her. Woha. :eek:

And who says it wouldn't be twisted? ;)

And we see the birht of lexana happening in the next episode. Lex gives her the serum and then saves her from it. wow what a hero. YUCK!!

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:26 PM

I happen to like this twisted ship, mind you all. :D

myankskent

03-30-2006, 09:27 PM

Originally posted by Aloof
Hey, it's my favorite ship. I don't care what happens, it's sick and twisted and dark. IMO of course.

Alright, well I hope we don't lose another viewer when Lexana ends by season 6. Sounds like you'll stop watching this show once Lexana is over. It seems to be the only reason that you watch this show.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:27 PM

Originally posted by myankskent
Point is if it's twisted then Lex really doesn't care about Lana. I don't want to hear people shout that they are both meant for each other when Lex is putting Lana in danger to get what he wants. Come on now.

Clark is a moron, but at least he never puts Lana in danger. He just gives her emotional pain. Lex will give her physical pain if it means finding out what he wants.

i see lana finding out clark's secret from lionel. She then breaks up with lex, lex knows lionel did sometrhing to cause this break-up so he kiolls his father and torchers lana for information on why she broke up with him (im thinking he thinks some info points to clark)

Fly by guy

03-30-2006, 09:29 PM

Originally posted by jason127
i think just about every fan no matter what ship you support is angry about this break up (except lexana fans). The writers did it poorly and not in class at all, Having clark tell her he didnt love her sucked. Im sure no matter what ship you support you didnt wanna see them end it on these terms. All i can do is try to get through the lexana scenes in the following episodes with a barf bag, and just hope that lexana is done with by the season finale and lana knows clark's secret.
From your typing fingers to TPTB.
Can't t y p e, k.... n......i.......f.... e......... i. n .......b..... a......c.....k

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 09:30 PM

Originally posted by jason127
i see lana finding out clark's secret from lionel. She then breaks up with lex, lex knows lionel did sometrhing to cause this break-up so he kiolls his father and torchers lana for information on why she broke up with him (im thinking he thinks some info points to clark)

It sounds like YOU should be writing on this show. You think they're that capable? :rolleyes:

Originally posted by Fly by guy
From your typing fingers to TPTB.
Can't t y p e, k n i f e i n b a c k

:lol: I'm with you.

Aloof

03-30-2006, 09:31 PM

Originally posted by myankskent
Alright, well I hope we don't lose another viewer when Lexana ends by season 6. Sounds like you'll stop watching this show once Lexana is over. It seems to be the only reason that you watch this show.

No, that's not the only reason why I watch this show. And even if Lexana ends, I'll keep watching.

OutlawAngel

03-30-2006, 09:31 PM

ferd

03-30-2006, 09:32 PM

When was the last time someone saw a 'good' breakup?

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:32 PM

clark's gonna feel the same emotional pain as lana felt tonight, when he finds out about lexana. Doesnt he break his telescope??? All he can do is blame his stupid self, i hate how the wirters portray clark in his love life. Doesnt Tom welling also walk around thye set and say, "Clark is an idiot??" I would like to see some Red K used in one of these episodes coming up, Maybe in mercy because we havent heard alot of news about that episode yet and since lana and lex just kissed the previous episode it would setup clark for an emotional blow and Here comes Red K. Just one episode where we dont need alot of emotion although in the end clark will probably do something he will regret infront of lana and push her further torward lex.

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:33 PM

Just because people keep mentioning it, I don't see Lex torturing Lana. Manipulating, yes, torturing, no. Just because he did it in the comics back in 1986 (Which was retconned in Birthright) does not mean it will happen on Smallville.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:34 PM

Originally posted by cotton candy girl
It sounds like YOU should be writing on this show. You think they're that intrepid? :rolleyes:

:lol: I'm with you.

HA HA HA HA you guys are hilarious. think i managed to spell that right. (i hope) lol i type fast and dont check my spelling didn't know it was a big deal to some people.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 09:35 PM

Originally posted by ferd
When was the last time someone saw a 'good' breakup?

No, just more dignified, ya know. :\

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:37 PM

Originally posted by ferd
When was the last time someone saw a 'good' breakup?

As if they couldn't make it better? Yeah, right. God, leave it some dignity writers, huh? We need Al & Miles back! When are they gonna realize that playing in the kiddie pool with Aquatool is a joke?

Monica_O

03-30-2006, 09:37 PM

Oh well... actually I just hope this "breakup" is now for real!! I don't like Clana :(

hugs, be well and take care, Monica

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:37 PM

Originally posted by SmallvilleMan
hahaaha, dignified? Dignified? How can it be dignified after this episode? HOW? First off, Clark denies loving her, everyone says Lana is going to hate clark, martha says Clark doesn't think Lana is the one. Dignified? I know the breakup had to happen, but what is so bad about this kind of breakup:

Clark: Lana as much as I love you, we can't be together anymore. I know you don't understand, but I can't be hones with you and i can't keep hurting you like this.

What's so hard about him saying that or letting him say that? They destroyed clana into dust, then took a crap on it.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That would have been better then I dont love you anymore when he clearly does.

myankskent

03-30-2006, 09:38 PM

Originally posted by muffinpeddler
Just because people keep mentioning it, I don't see Lex torturing Lana. Manipulating, yes, torturing, no. Just because he did it in the comics back in 1986 (Which was retconned in Birthright) does not mean it will happen on Smallville.

He can torture her by using someone else that can't be connected to him. It is said that a rogue doctor injects Clark with the serum. How much do you want to bet that this doctor works for Lex.

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 09:39 PM

Originally posted by amberdawn
I completely agree. And I actually felt bad for Lana in this episode. What a way to kick her in the teeth.

Well I think what he said to his mom was his bottom line. He could either lie to her, becasue she wouldn't let him break up with her if he admitted he still loved her, or tell her his secret.

If he told her he still loved her, her next question would be then why can't we be together. Which leads to him having to tell her his secret, or just breaking up with her for seemingly no reason which would drive her crazy and still pining for him and not to mention still waiting for him to come around him, noneof which he wants. He wants her to be with someone who can give her what she wants.

So I honestly dont blame him. I question to some extent him not telling her the secret, but if he has his reasons he has his reasons. And like Martha said and like he didn't exactly deny, deep down he knows she's not the one

OutlawAngel

03-30-2006, 09:40 PM

Originally posted by shirkie
But Lana isn't "supposed" to end up with Lex... She's "supposed" to end up with Pete. Right? I mean, that's obviously not going to happen anytime in the near future, what with Pete being in Wichita and all (anyone else appreciate the reference to Aunt Nell, who we've now confirmed has not disappeared off the face of the earth), but Lex and Lana don't stay together overall.
shirkie

My mom thought I had gone totally crazy when I started screaming 'She is is alive! Aunt Nell is alive! Holy cow its a miracle!!!'

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:42 PM

Originally posted by OutlawAngel
My mom thought I had gone totally crazy when I started screaming 'She is is alive! Aunt Nell is alive! Holy cow its a miracle!!!'

:rotfl: :rotfl:

Originally posted by SlickBlonde
.

So I honestly dont blame him. I question to some extent him not telling her the secret, but if he has his reasons he has his reasons. And like Martha said and like he didn't exactly deny, deep down he knows she's not the one

We know his reasons, and they're pathetic.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 09:44 PM

Originally posted by muffinpeddler
We know his reasons, and they're pathetic.

Right on!

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:44 PM

Thank you.

cotton candy girl

03-30-2006, 09:46 PM

You're welcome.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:46 PM

well i always thought smallville was gonna be about clana but who knows now that i think they have ended clana romantic for good they might move forward with clois which means we are closer to the superman destiny and closer to seeing smallville end its series. If we get clois in season 6 which i think is defintely too early but if we do i see season 6 being the final season of smallville.

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 09:47 PM

Originally posted by muffinpeddler
:rotfl: :rotfl:

We know his reasons, and they're pathetic.

Yeh im not disagreeing with the fact thats his reasons are pathetic. I moving on to the fact that, given he feels he cant be honest with her about his secret (and lets just assume for the sake of arguement he cant tell her), lying to her about loving her was the only way to go. Otherwise she would still be waiting for him and pining for him, which ironically is what happens in the comics

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:49 PM

Yeah, she has a pretty pathetic life in the cmics...leaving her panties in Lois' bed and whatnot.

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 09:53 PM

Originally posted by muffinpeddler
Yeah, she has a pretty pathetic life in the cmics...leaving her panties in Lois' bed and whatnot.

Yeh, see, we dont want Lana to end up like that. As far as Im concerned Clarks just looking out for, giving her the necessary to move on. As long as she believes he still oves her, she'll never go away, move on, however you want to put it

BoguszX

03-30-2006, 09:55 PM

I dont really give a damn.
Its about time it ended now that the crap is done with and all the fillers gone lets get some real action into these episodes!

MBCorp

03-30-2006, 09:56 PM

Interesting how Clark breaks up with Lana because he doesn't want to see her get hurt anymore, and yet this probably hurts her worse than anything else that could have happened. I'm a bit confused by Clark's reasoning in this instance.

SacredK

03-30-2006, 09:57 PM

Originally posted by BoguszX
I dont really give a damn.
Its about time it ended now that the crap is done with and all the fillers gone lets get some real action into these episodes!

:rotfl:

HAHAHAHA. I don't care much either.

muffinpeddler

03-30-2006, 09:58 PM

Originally posted by BoguszX
I dont really give a damn.
Its about time it ended now that the crap is done with and all the fillers gone lets get some real action into these episodes!

And the next episode doesn't look like filler to you?

Nospam

03-30-2006, 09:58 PM

Originally posted by ferd
When was the last time someone saw a 'good' breakup?

On TV? Probably never. In real life? Often. At least between two good people that know when something is over. It happens. That's why we watch though; it's not reality. If it was, I may as just turn my couch to face outside and watch my neighbor's window.

jason127

03-30-2006, 09:58 PM

Originally posted by SlickBlonde
Yeh im not disagreeing with the fact thats his reasons are pathetic. I moving on to the fact that, given he feels he cant be honest with her about his secret (and lets just assume for the sake of arguement he cant tell her), lying to her about loving her was the only way to go. Otherwise she would still be waiting for him and pining for him, which ironically is what happens in the comics

although im really pissed about the breakup i can see what your saying. If he didnt tell her he didnt love her anymore she would just tell him to tell her the truth, well this time he acftully got her to believe that he doesnt love her anymore.

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 10:02 PM

Well I suppose he could continue to hurt her for a few more years, slow and painfull-like, or quick and agonizing. I would prefer the latter, but thats just me. I'd rather be able to move on, than stay stuck in the emotional rut of not being able to be with someone I love and who loves me, for some unknown reason

Originally posted by MBCorp
Interesting how Clark breaks up with Lana because he doesn't want to see her get hurt anymore, and yet this probably hurts her worse than anything else that could have happened. I'm a bit confused by Clark's reasoning in this instance.

Zungas

03-30-2006, 10:07 PM

Thankfully Lana doesn't have to put up with Clarks bs anymore.

ferd

03-30-2006, 10:07 PM

Originally posted by Nospam
On TV? Probably never. In real life? Often. At least between two good people that know when something is over. It happens. That's why we watch though; it's not reality. If it was, I may as just turn my couch to face outside and watch my neighbor's window.

I want to break up with you NoSpam. :lol: The ones I've witnessed are fodder for Jerry Springer. I think the fact that Clark and Lana didn't throw things or drop the F bomb constitues a dignified split.

Don't worry, I'm sure they'll be laughing and having coffee in the Talon in a week or two. ;)

globalbudd3

03-30-2006, 10:08 PM

Well, for this Clana fan, I agree that the whole break up thing is a joke. But I guess this is the best the writers could conjure up to why these two are not meant to be together. It is becoming a SV cliche now. But no matter what, we all knew from the beginning that Clana was not meant to be so therefore this Clana fan is moving on...LOL.

But regardless, Tom and Kristen did a wonderful job.

Jokerisdaking

03-30-2006, 10:17 PM

Patch123

03-30-2006, 10:25 PM

This is Lex, he's an evil mastermind with the hots for Lana, but can he see why kids love the sweet cinnamon taste of cinnamon toast crunch cereal?

^^^ what tha heck is that supposed to mean..?? lol???

but ima clana fan and i really wanted them together....

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 10:26 PM

KrissO

03-30-2006, 10:28 PM

This could prove Clark has grown up yes. He wants to protect Lana from more lies and go on with his life.
But why oh why can he not tell her the secret ? :/ What are the writers goals here seriously, to hurt the fans ? They're surely gonna lose a lot of fans if they don't fix this very fast.
Because if this just goes over to the Superman story we all know straight away, then there's nothing new. Then I'm done with this show.

And the stuff Martha said in the end, what a joke. Sorry, that just didn't fit in. She's always been suportive about them, but this one time she wasn't. That's just ridiculous... they can't just change a character like that!

This was all a joke :/

ferd

03-30-2006, 10:30 PM

Originally posted by SlickBlonde
You're my new favorite poster. I couldn't agree more. He made a really diffcult choice, and in my opinion he made the right one

Word. I posted something very similar in one of the many threads on this subject.

To rip off Spidey 2 for the second time tonight "There are greater things at work here than Clark and Lana."

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 10:31 PM

Originally posted by KrissO

And the stuff Martha said in the end, what a joke. Sorry, that just didn't fit in. She's always been suportive about them, but this one time she wasn't. That's just ridiculous... they can't just character like that!

This was all a joke :/

Actually Martha has said the very same thing before. If forget which episode, but right after she says maybe Lanas not the one, Clark says he couldn't picture loving anyone else and then lois pulls up in her Fix-Or-Repair-Daily (sorry, little ford joke) Fusion

sari_chem

03-30-2006, 10:39 PM

Were the writers hinting (through Martha) that Lana might join the Dark side? I don't want to see that. Lana is a "good" character. I don't want to see her go all evil, especially over a guy.

ferd

03-30-2006, 10:41 PM

I think they were shouting it with a big megaphone.

Although I'm personally praying they don't go there. :\

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 10:46 PM

Originally posted by ferd

To rip off Spidey 2 for the second time tonight "There are greater things at work here than Clark and Lana."

I love that! K-site, should put that on the front page

superspider02

03-30-2006, 10:50 PM

i am actually glad it is over but i agree it could have been done alot about actually their whoel relationship could have been written better but stupid writers.

Fly by guy

03-30-2006, 10:59 PM

Originally posted by Jokerisdaking
Okay alot of people here are kinda missing the point of Clarks conversation with Martha, the breakup is not just about not being willing to tell her the secret, Its about the fact that he has realized for himself that while Clark may or may not still have feelings for Lana he has realized that she is not the one. So he did the mature thing and ended the relationship, All the people on this thread screaming that Clakr needs to grow up should realize that he has. He made a hard descision. Continuing to be in a relationship that Clark inwardly realizes is not going to work or become something permanent is not being fair to either of them.
Besides this episode, when did Clark realize Lana was not the one? Reckoning, he proposed as he told Chloe, he was afraid of losing her and he loves her too much. Cyborg, I'll always love you no matter what happens. Inwardly, he may be confused because he has been afraid to even kiss his own girlfriend for fear he can't control himself. I think he broke it off because inwardly, he sees no way to tell Lana without her being in danger and he can think of no way of avoiding that danger. She was willing to wait, he wasn't man enough to try. Chloe knows, Lex knows she knows and she survives. Tell Lana the secret and all he knows about Lex and THEN break it off. If Clark wants something to grow it should be a pair. Heartless jerk.

SlickBlonde

03-30-2006, 11:07 PM

Originally posted by Fly by guy
Besides this episode, when did Clark realize Lana was not the one? Reckoning, he proposed as he told Chloe, he was afraid of losing her and he loves her too much. Cyborg, I'll always love you no matter what happens. Inwardly, he may be confused because he has been afraid to even kiss his own girlfriend for fear he can't control himself. I think he broke it off because inwardly, he sees no way to tell Lana without her being in danger and he can think of no way of avoiding that danger. She was willing to wait, he wasn't man enough to try. Chloe knows, Lex knows she knows and she survives. Tell Lana the secret and all he knows about Lex and THEN break it off. If Clark wants something to grow it should be a pair. Heartless jerk.

Honestly I find merit in your quote and the qoute you disagree with. I initially thought that telling her, then breaking it off with her would be his best bet. But after seeing how terrible she is with hiding her emotion/secrets with Lex in Reckoning, i thought twice about that. I figure if people want know about him, they'll come after those he's loved regardless of what they know, at least if she doesn't know they'll be able to see it written all over her face and may not get to point of torturing her.

And also I think the poster was talking about the fact that when Martha said maybe he knows deep down she isn't the one, he didn't exactly deny it. I thought the writers were gonna try to pull this card when Martha said the same thing a few episodes back.

pacifichic

03-30-2006, 11:09 PM

I am SOOOOO Friggin Mad right now! what in the world? That was just about the dumbest thing ever. Clark says he was trying to be all noble...but he just made himself into the biggest jerk ever. That was flat out cruel and cold what he did. I really want some happy Clana to be going on! not this stuff...:( Lana has always been the one, and he knows that! Even when he forgot EVERYTHING in that one ep. he still realized that he loved her! No more of this "protection" stuff. I say he should tell her and let her make her own decision

bunkmania

03-30-2006, 11:10 PM

I AM SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HAPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPY. THE RETARDED RELATIONSHIP IS FINALLY OVER FOR LIFE. 4 LIFE4 LIFE4 LIFE4 LIFE4 LIFE4 LIFE!!

MOVE FORWARD CLARK!

myankskent

03-30-2006, 11:11 PM

Originally posted by SlickBlonde
Honestly I find merit in your quote and the qoute you disagree with. I initially thought that telling her, then breaking it off with her would be his best bet. But after seeing how terrible she is with hiding her emotion/secrets with Lex in Reckoning, i thought twice about that. I figure if people want know about him, they'll come after those he's loved regardless of what they know, at least if she doesn't know they'll be able to see it written all over her face and may not get to point of torturing her.

And also I think the poster was talking about the fact that when Martha said maybe he knows deep down she isn't the one, he didn't exactly deny it. I thought the writers were gonna try to pull this card when Martha said the same thing a few episodes back.

And just how does Clark know that lana can't handle herself around Lex? Clark is never in the room to witness this so how can he know that Lana can't keep anything from Lex? The events in Reckoning were a one time deal. You're telling me that based on that, Clark can come to the conclusion that Lana can't handle keeping a secret? Especially after she would've died in that accident if not for Clark's heroics.

Also, Clark was kind of told the wrong information on the phone from Lana. Lana told him that Lex knows about him and that she doesn't know how but Lex knows. Well Lex doesn't know the truth because Lana never told him. I'm not sure that Clark is aware of this.

Nospam

03-30-2006, 11:11 PM

Originally posted by ferd
I want to break up with you NoSpam. :lol: The ones I've witnessed are fodder for Jerry Springer. I think the fact that Clark and Lana didn't throw things or drop the F bomb constitues a dignified split.

Don't worry, I'm sure they'll be laughing and having coffee in the Talon in a week or two. ;)

Well, maybe it's the people I hang out with. :) I have to ask, do you live in a trailer park? I swear, trailer parks are the nexus of the strange and bizarre.

ferd

03-30-2006, 11:14 PM

Ouch! That was below the belt.

And no I live in a house.

And last time I checked Smallville was pretty chock full of the strange and bizarre, and Lex lives there in a mansion.

Freaks and those who break up dramatically litter the world at every class. ;)

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 11:16 PM

Okay alot of people here are kinda missing the point of Clarks conversation with Martha, the breakup is not just about not being willing to tell her the secret, Its about the fact that he has realized for himself that while Clark may or may not still have feelings for Lana he has realized that she is not the one. So he did the mature thing and ended the relationship, All the people on this thread screaming that Clakr needs to grow up should realize that he has. He made a hard descision. Continuing to be in a relationship that Clark inwardly realizes is not going to work or become something permanent is not being fair to either of them

No, he isn't grown up. Being a grown means being straight foward with people, especially the ones you love. Being a grown up, would have Clark been telling her that he did love her, but couldn't be with her. He took the easy out, because he doesnt want to live witht he consequences of telling her again. He took the coward's way out.

God-Man

03-30-2006, 11:23 PM

I wish that when Clark was going to break up with Lana, it was because he was sure that he did not love her with all his heart. I got the feeling that he is still depply in love with her, and that we'll see Clark moping around, pining for Lana.

sdogg1m

03-30-2006, 11:25 PM

I don't know if I buy into the whole, "if you love her then protect her" idea. She obviously loved Clark. That being the case then he should have told her and then let her decide. However, that would change the whole makeup of the show and the producers would not get what they want which is: Lex and Lana

SmallvilleMan

03-30-2006, 11:26 PM

Exactly. That's the kind of breakup, even Clana fans want. From what i've heard about spoliers, Clark's character is going to be dragged through the mud. Ending clana right, imo, is the step toward making clark superman.

I don't know if I buy into the whole, "if you love her then protect her" idea. She obviously loved Clark

I do, not just because I'm a clana fan, but because if I were Clark i might do the same thing. We all do anything we can to protect the ones we love.

MBCorp

03-30-2006, 11:27 PM

Originally posted by God-Man
I wish that when Clark was going to break up with Lana, it was because he was sure that he did not love her with all his heart. I got the feeling that he is still depply in love with her, and that we'll see Clark moping around, pining for Lana.

Yeah, exactly. That's one reason why I'm not exactly cheering the way they've broken Clana up. I get the feeling that no matter what Martha says Clark is still hung up over Lana.