No Clana Sex 2nite

[chitaunny]

Man, they are really going to drag this thing on:lol: :lol: :lol: :rolleyes:

[shy175223]

Wait until the very end. At least unilt the shows over.

[chitaunny]

here we go!!!!!

[shy175223]

told ya!

[Da Rook]

No sex tonight - Clark will have his powers back by shows end!

[MediaGuy0979]

Actually.....

[AnimeJoe]

Whooo Hooo, GO CLARK & LANA,, heat up the room! :D

[shy175223]

wrong Thye finally did the deed even though its never shown

[chrismen]

No he still doesn't have powers and they did have sex. Might I add that this was a lot more tastfull then if it had happened before.

[MidgardDragon]

Looked like they went for it to me. Obviously they aren't going to show "the deed" happen on screen. Especially after all the complaining last season about how the show was supposedly getting too racy. It was heavily implied that they did "it" once the camera rolled by and the end credits started.

[k18]

There was definitely some Clana sex tonight. It may not have been shown but it happened off screen. Lana and her shirt off? WOW, she's hot! All the girls were hot in this episode! There was some Chloevage and Lana taking her shirt off. I need to go and take a cold shower.

[corkyfuzz]

it was a bit uncomfortable watching this episode with my parents in the room. ha, but i'm glad it was done as tastefully as it could have been.

[k18]

I would imagine so, corkyfuzz. Don't worry, you're not the only who has been in that type of situation before.

[beatles4]

Clark "came" with a speeding bullet! We missed it perhaps? LOL

[MBCorp]

They were going to have sex. They can't actually show the sex onscreen. And the next episode will probably start with a morning after scene with Clark and Lana lying next to each other in one another's arms.

[Kris-El]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

CLANA SEX!!!!!!!!!!!!!

and it was sweet, and beautiful.

hooray!

[Rosey]

The deed is done. Done off camera, but it's done.

Too bad they were interrupted earlier or we could have had a whole show of it.

I was surprised though how CLana just agreed not to talk, to put all of their curiosity aside and start fresh. I'd still want to KNOW a few things!!

[amberdawn]

Im glad its over with.

[LoisNClark]

i like how they handled the sex thing...they didn't go overboard with it but hinted that they did it and kept all the rest of it off camera

[dizzy]

Yeah what happened to the pollow sences with them looking at each other or maybe thats next week and they have the sence continue there

[smallvillerocks45]

Sorry to sound so sappy, but it was simply romantic...I couldn't have imagined how they handled it any better.

---This is the best show on television.---

[tmkfan]

O mannnnnnnn the banging scene......... god this whole episode was a dream come true!

[Rafael122]

They even played some Coldplay, what a great choice. Barry White should have been in the CD Player, but thats just nitpicking.

[Wheelz]

I'm going to laugh if the next episode starts where this one ended and they get interupted before doing the deed.

Clark and Lana shouldn't be having sex. He hasn't even told her that he's an alien. When you are about to lose your virginity to someone (and vice versa), it is proper ettiquette to let them know what planet you were born on. Superman told Lois before he nailed her, didn't he? Now lana is going to be all pissed off when she finds out she gave it up to someone she didn't know as well as she thought she did.

[Kreukie]

Originally posted by Wheelz
I'm going to laugh if the next episode starts where this one ended and they get interupted before doing the deed.

Clark and Lana shouldn't be having sex. He hasn't even told her that he's an alien. When you are about to lose your virginity to someone (and vice versa), it is proper ettiquette to let them know what planet you were born on. Superman told Lois before he nailed her, didn't he? Now lana is going to be all pissed off when she finds out she gave it up to someone she didn't know as well as she thought she did.

Shhh. You're ruining the mood.

I have the talon scene on a loop. :D

[LexLuthorMetropolis]

I'm just glad it's out of the way and we're moving on.

[tmkfan]

DUDE THEY HAD SEX. GET OVER IT.

[The Astronomer]

Maybe now Clark will tell her about himself like he always promised. How about that for after-sex pillow talk . . . "Lana, my real nam is Kal-El. You know, the guy the two super baddies were looking for . . . "

[aqua]

I'm happy that it was done tastefully. I was pleasantly surprised. ;)

I'm happy that it was done tastefully. I was pleasantly surprised. ;)

[smoky]

Al Gough said Clark, for some reason, will NOT be honest with Lana.

[superspider02]

i had a feeling they where going to do something like this. I agree it was done nicely and it implyed that they are doing the deed. We know they wont have show full out sex on the show with it rating it has but the scene was done well.

[gtjsasso-el]

I am glad that they didn't show it. Nasty! I was so relieved when they were interrupted the first time they tried. I guess I knew it was coming, but that relationship is so horrible. But hell, if I was Clark I guess I'd try to get w/ Lana too.

[UDStyle]

What are you talking about? Did you post this before seeing the end?

THEY GOT DOWN! lol

Hmmm hope Clark used a condom.

Congradulations Lana and Clark, 4 years of.. hmmm not sure what to call it.. well it's paid off. The best part is that I was scared that it would happen in the barn which would be the worst hick cliche they could do to the character. The talon was a much better place.

[phoephoe]

it would have been weird in the barn

[djpnutz]

y the candles? Just wondering. It seemed like they had power in the Talon... =\

[Tabbymarie]

Originally posted by Wheelz
I'm going to laugh if the next episode starts where this one ended and they get interupted before doing the deed.

Clark and Lana shouldn't be having sex. He hasn't even told her that he's an alien. When you are about to lose your virginity to someone (and vice versa), it is proper ettiquette to let them know what planet you were born on. Superman told Lois before he nailed her, didn't he? Now lana is going to be all pissed off when she finds out she gave it up to someone she didn't know as well as she thought she did.

*makes mental notes for the future - be sure to tell future first that I am from earth*

I really think they did this scene very tastefully done too. it dispells the idea that sex usually doesn't live up to your hopes and dreams the first time. Since this is superman, we'll just assume it was that and better.

[nsuck1]

OH COME ON!!!

Gross! totally gross! Wait about 2 weeks and she is going to be back to her old self again... Whining and crying that life sucks. Well its good taht they didnt show anything too racy... god knows i didnt want to see it. I cant wait to see what happens at the beginning of the next episode, but ihope they dont draw it out...

[Shadow09]

Originally posted by beatles4
Clark "came" with a speeding bullet! We missed it perhaps? LOL

:rotfl: Omg this is too funny

[gtjsasso-el]

How do you think Lana will react when he tells her that he is an alien with super powers? I'll bet she'll be pretty sore that her first time was with a little green man.

[jadkins555]

I hated it. I'm not anti Lana, I just don't think that it should have happened when he ends up with Lois in the end.

[cowbellallen]

Kent parents are probably going to confront him about it when he comes home the next day though. Geez Lana will feel super awkward around them after that...

I didn't like that they uh, did the thing. Too many morals going away...

[chitaunny]

Clark "came" with a speeding bullet. LOL LOL LOL LOL:lol: :lol: :lol: I just hope he wore a "bullet proof vest". Like some of you I am just glad that it is over and done with and now we can move on. I did not really want them to have sex, but I must admit that bringing back the clana has helped the ratings. I want to see this show last about two more seasons so this had to be done. I also must agree it was very tasefully done. Very sweet and romantic.

[MediaGuy0979]

Man is Clark going to get it when Lana finally finds out about his secret and realizes Chloe knew all along but Lana didn't. "I'm your girlfriend, you should have told me! We had sex together!!! Now I'm pregnant with your alien kid!!!! I hate you!" :rotfl:

[gtjsasso-el]

alien kids are funny.

[ImzadiJedi]

Why? Why? Why? I thought Clark would of listened more to his parents... and not to little Clark Junior... :rolleyes:

[LuckyKrypto]

Originally posted by corkyfuzz
it was a bit uncomfortable watching this episode with my parents in the room. ha, but i'm glad it was done as tastefully as it could have been.

Try being the parent watching it with all of your children. ;)

My 5 year old wants to know "Why is he taking his shirt off?":eek:

[Kryptomaniac]

Originally posted by corkyfuzz
it was a bit uncomfortable watching this episode with my parents in the room. ha, but i'm glad it was done as tastefully as it could have been.

Ditto. And can you believe it? Last time my family crowded around to watch SMALLVILLE with me was the eppy...you guessed it...RELIC!!!!! Had to jump up and fan the TV during that one, too. :rotfl:

[OneWayFilms]

I am very sad that our hero and role model for American youth has sucummed to LUST and given himself to Lana outside of marriage. At least as Kal-El, he was willing to get MARRIED first before doing the nasty...but with Lana, and as Clark, all morals just went flying right out the door, and pure LUST took over.

He doesn't even love her enough to be honest with her, he still living his LIES and will not be honest with her. What kind of a relationship can this be based on? No truth, no honesty, no trust.

Ok, now that I said all that...I DO praise the show for at LEAST not showing us the deed. Leaving it to our imagination was perhaps the BEST way to have it done....IMPLYING it and not showing it. THANK YOU....this is a pleasant change from most of the episodes from season 4.

However....Clark never actually DID it in season 4 either.

Well, once he DOES get his powers back, I dont see where he and Lana are going to be able to keep THIS up....one attempt at THAT again, and he cook her to a crisp with his heat vision. Jeesh, the whole TOWN would explode if he tried this WITH his powers. I suppose he better enjoy it while he can.

Hmmmm, hows he gonna tell Lana after he gets the powers back that they cant do IT again?

[sdogg1m]

Well if Clark did indeed do the deed then now he can cast Lana aside and its about time.

[Danelle]

I'm going to be honest here. I don't like Lana, I don't care much for Clana, and I most certainly don't like any inkling of Lexana. But you know what? I like how they went about this episode! I hate Lana most of the time, because of her whiney "me me me" attitude, and the only time when I can stand her is when she's knocked unconscious or truly with Clark. Like those two episodes they were "dating" in Season 2...I thought they were cute. But then that blew up and she's back to being annoying again.

When the first episode of this season aired and I saw that Clana would be born again, I groaned. I'm getting bored of their off and on chase. BUT, when Lana and Clark where in the barn, getting ready to do "it" for the first time, I couldn't help silently cheering them on. I don't know why! When they're actually together, they're kind of cute. But when Clark gets his powers back, we'll revert to the "secrets and lies" Lana that got old 3 seasons ago.

But anyway, I'm not disappointed that they lost their virginity to each other, even though Lana is not Clark's true love. I'd say he should save himself for Lois in the future, but she's not exactly a virgin either, is she? Oh, well, what's done is done, and I'm glad Smallville went about this tastefully (for once). :)

[Jor'el_Ted]

When Clark and Lana layed down on the floor i was silently cheering. Finaly Clark looses his virginity and who better than the beautiful Lana to loose it too! And doin it infron of the fireplace can't get anymore special than that! :D When they were both asking if they did it i thought about how close Clark came to havin sex with Alicia(why the hell did she half ta take that necklace off him).

I was crackin up when Clark was in the air vent and Chloe was like "What?! Pete got to see your spaceship?!". And when she comented about Clark's "super-whining" was priceless. :lol:

[UDStyle]

Lana having alien kids? I smell a spinoff idea!

[vyperman7]

The writers are going to get themselves in trouble with this one. It has always been that Clark lost his virginity to Lois when they got married. Now that they have made the audience assume that Clark and Lana slept together, it is going to raise hell with the Clana shippers, when they pull a rewind. They are using the fact that Clark is normal as an excuse for it to not really count. Then in order for Clark to get his powers back, and be brought back from the dead, Jor-El will rewind what has happened, so neither Clark or Lana will remember they slept together. That is my guess anyway. From the films, they have shown that Kryptonians can go back in time.

Personally, I think this is a lame copout, and I wish they would have gone about it another way.

[tmkfan]

that is not going to happen..

[vyperman7]

I could see it happening though. Clark and Lana are not supposed to sleep together. So what is the one way to make it seem like it never happened? I am not trying to deny it happened. I am just saying that I would not be a bit suprised if they pulled a rewind.

[GatorTex]

Honestly, I hope you're wrong vyperman7. The whole time travel thing was super lame in the movies and if that's brought up in Smallville...ultra corny! Here's hoping this doesn't happen.

[Danelle]

That's an interesting theory, vyperman7, but I don't know if I buy it. That would be a HUGE cop-out, even by Smallville standards. But if they did do a "rewind," and Clana sex never happened...then it would also mean that the Clex fight never happened. So would Clark and Lex go back to being good buds?

[vyperman7]

The writers love to leave themselves loopholes. They always give you what you want to see, when there is a way for it to not really count. Look at the flying. "Kal-El can fly. Clark Kent is still earth bound."

Now is it any coincedence, that it finally happens between Clark and Lana, when Clark is normal? The writers are probably thinking that since Clark is normal, that it doesn't really count, and there has to be a way that Jor-El can bring Clark back from the dead.

I hate the timetravel thing as well, but with how the writers are, and with the history of the character, I would not be a bit suprised for Jor-El to pull a rewind, and Clark himself will be stuck with the memory of what happened, and Lana won't remember.

Originally posted by Danelle
That's an interesting theory, vyperman7, but I don't know if I buy it. That would be a HUGE cop-out, even by Smallville standards. But if they did do a "rewind," and Clana sex never happened...then it would also mean that the Clex fight never happened. So would Clark and Lex go back to being good buds?

Good point.

However, Clark himself would be left with the memory of what happened, so Lex would not recall anything, but Clark would still remember. In order to make a friendship work, both people have to be in it.

I don't like the timetravel idea. I hate it actually. I just think it is a weird coincedence, that it happens when Clark is normal, and the previews for next week have Clark dying as a mortal.

[ma200]

the problem with this time travel theory, IMO, is that nobody is gonna be happy at all if it happened.

[Jor'el_Ted]

Originally posted by vyperman7
The writers are going to get themselves in trouble with this one. It has always been that Clark lost his virginity to Lois when they got married. Now that they have made the audience assume that Clark and Lana slept together, it is going to raise hell with the Clana shippers, when they pull a rewind. They are using the fact that Clark is normal as an excuse for it to not really count. Then in order for Clark to get his powers back, and be brought back from the dead, Jor-El will rewind what has happened, so neither Clark or Lana will remember they slept together. That is my guess anyway. From the films, they have shown that Kryptonians can go back in time.

Personally, I think this is a lame copout, and I wish they would have gone about it another way.

Dude, that was back in the day when people weren't big on pre-marital sex. It's 2005, they gotta do somethin ta spice up the show. Also, i'm not married myself but i know that you usualy don't wanna tell yer wife how many girls you've slept with in the past. :)

I'm seriously hopin yer wrong though, for this end up as a total rewind would cause alot of people to bomb the writers with angry hate mail. There was something similar to this in Stargate where the big scene which made all the shippers jumpin for joy only took place in an alternate timeline. :)

[Danelle]

Yes, but if Clark remembers that he lost his virginity to Lana, even if the "rewind" causes her to forget, can't he still technically say he had sex with Lana? It happened, he remembers...she doesn't. That doesn't take away from the fact that it happened, much in the sense that you say Clark would not be friends with Lex because he (Clark) would remember what happened. Does that make any sense?

[~*Lois & Clark Fan*~]

Originally posted by vyperman7
The writers love to leave themselves loopholes. They always give you what you want to see, when there is a way for it to not really count. Look at the flying. "Kal-El can fly. Clark Kent is still earth bound."

Now is it any coincedence, that it finally happens between Clark and Lana, when Clark is normal? The writers are probably thinking that since Clark is normal, that it doesn't really count, and there has to be a way that Jor-El can bring Clark back from the dead.

I hate the timetravel thing as well, but with how the writers are, and with the history of the character, I would not be a bit suprised for Jor-El to pull a rewind, and Clark himself will be stuck with the memory of what happened, and Lana won't remember.



Good point.

However, Clark himself would be left with the memory of what happened, so Lex would not recall anything, but Clark would still remember. In order to make a friendship work, both people have to be in it.

I don't like the timetravel idea. I hate it actually. I just think it is a weird coincedence, that it happens when Clark is normal, and the previews for next week have Clark dying as a mortal.

Ryan great post :) I firmly believe there's a reason that they made Clark mortal so that he could be with Lana intimately, I still say there's more to it than a "loophole" It would be just like Al and Miles to throw fanbases a bone, then snatch it away, I honestly think they get their jollies from doing that. The time travel rewind thing I could totally see, Al and Miles could then say, "Hey you got your sex scene, we gave you what we said we would"


Anyways, unless they mention the "sex" next week, I say it's left up to the imagination, that "sex scene" was a major snoozefest if you can call that a sex scene with their clothes on ;)

[ma200]

Originally posted by Danelle
Yes, but if Clark remembers that he lost his virginity to Lana, even if the "rewind" causes her to forget, can't he still technically say he had sex with Lana? It happened, he remembers...she doesn't. That doesn't take away from the fact that it happened, much in the sense that you say Clark would not be friends with Lex because he (Clark) would remember what happened. Does that make any sense?

This is why i won't be happy either way. i will never really understand why clark had sex so soon especially when he lost his powers; a huge physical part of himself. it's like having sex without your limb. it's just not the same.

If i were him, I would want to have sex when I'm completely physically and emotionally myself. It just feels so much more fullfilling that way.

[Kreukie]

Originally posted by ma200
If i were him, I would want to have sex when I'm completely physically and emotionally myself. It just feels so much more fullfilling that way.

I think he will next week, like we saw in the trailer.

Lana running up to him after she sees that he's alive, they then go up to his room and go for round two... or three or four or five depending how it worked out for them before Clark got shot. :lol:

[~*Lois & Clark Fan*~]

So can we basically say Clark was half a man with Lana? :lol: Sorry it just makes me laugh that they had to make him mortal to have sex with Lana, there is just something majorly wrong with that :p

[vyperman7]

Thanks Angela.

You and me always seem to be on the same page.. :)

You do have to wonder why they made it happen when Clark is now a regular guy. If that is not an invitation for a loophole, I don't know what is... LOL

[Kreukie]

Originally posted by ~*Lois & Clark Fan*~
So can we basically say Clark was half a man with Lana? :lol: Sorry it just makes me laugh that they had to make him mortal to have sex with Lana, there is just something majorly wrong with that :p

They did the same thing with Clark and Lois in the movies.

[Jor'el_Ted]

Originally posted by ~*Lois & Clark Fan*~
....that "sex scene" was a major snoozefest if you can call that a sex scene with their clothes on ;)

Well they couldn't show the two of them naked on the floor now could they. :)

[Kreukie]

Originally posted by Jor'el_Ted
Well they couldn't show the two of them naked on the floor now could they. :)

They will soon enough! We still have that scene of Clark and Lana naked in bed to look forward to. :D

[~*Lois & Clark Fan*~]

Originally posted by Jor'el_Ted
Well they couldn't show the two of them naked on the floor now could they. :)


They showed Alicia in a short shirt and underpants in an episode when she and Clark didn't even do anything but kiss. So they could have showed more than they did if they'd wanted too ;) If Kristin was uncomfortable with showing her body, that's what body doubles are for. ;)

Originally posted by Kreukie
They did the same thing with Clark and Lois in the movies.

I haven't seen that movie in awhile, but he didn't become mortal just to have sex with her from what I remember, he became mortal by his own choice to be with Lois.

My point was on SV, they intentionally made him mortal so that he could be intimate with Lana, like I said there's something majorly wrong with that

Originally posted by vyperman7
Thanks Angela.

You and me always seem to be on the same page.. :)

You do have to wonder why they made it happen when Clark is now a regular guy. If that is not an invitation for a loophole, I don't know what is... LOL


It truly does get you to wondering doesn't it ;)

[angelus666]

Um what Happens when Clark get's his powers back and Lana feels frisky?

[Kreukie]

Originally posted by ~*Lois & Clark Fan*~
I haven't seen that movie in awhile, but he didn't become mortal just to have sex with her from what I remember, he became mortal by his own choice to be with Lois.

Clark didn't even choose to be mortal here on Smallville, what are you talking about?

In the Superman movie Clark talks to Lara and asks if there any way he can be with Lois. Lara tells him the only way is if he becomes human, so he does and right afterwards they have sex, not a day, week or month later... it was hours later it happens! If I remember correctly Lois was with him too when he goes to Lara!

Clark on Smallville didn't ask Jor-El or even Lara to take his powers away to be with Lana, it just happened!

[shy175223]

I doubt that the whole time travel thing will happen because it seems too farfetcehed really. first of all, it stems from a rumor that has not be proven and I hope that Almiles don't go that direction because it sounds pretyy dumb. maybe Jor-el will heal Clark in the hospital when everyone thinks he's dead and give him his powers back.

[cayayofm]

While I believe that the writters could do the reverse time thing I don't think it would happen, not only it would take the sex with Lana back, but will take back Lex and Clark confrontation, that was a huge step foward in the episode, that would be the saddest part. Last night I had hope again for the show, they put a little effort and we had an interesting plot, great continuity and huge plot developments, if they take all that away I will be dissapointed big time with this show.

[PETER WEST]

Originally posted by LexLuthorMetropolis
I'm just glad it's out of the way and we're moving on.

My Thoughts Exactly . NOW it's time for him to move forward into The Future .

KAL-EL RETURNS, next week. ;) And continues his "NEW" journey to fullfill his DESTINY!!!!

[superman_115]

It happens in the end as you all should have known it would.

It is Smallville, did you expect them to do it right away, come on. lol

[YeahRemyZero]

Wasn't it a bit quick considering a week ago, Lana could barely walk, Mrs Kent had a broken leg and the town survived a meteor storm and 2 Krazy Kryptonians to be going straight to sex. They just kissed in the hospital scene. I'm hoping the difference in episodes is like 4 months, cuz that was a damn fast relationship. It took David like 5 years of real dating Donna to finally get in those pants.

[superhippie2000]

the episode took place like a month later so everyone is healed. it was implied they have sex so hopefully thats it and we dont have to worry about them doing it anymore. im just wondering that if thats what breaks them up is when clark gets his powers back they cant have sex. guess clark and lana need to go to the show divorce court or maybe even jerry springer

[BrianD]

but then again, what if the rewind thing does take place? that would explain why in the trailer recaps lex tries to hit clark with a sword and the sword breaks. maybe the real lex/clark confrontation happens then instead of now. why else does lex try to hit clark again after he'd proven that hes human.

[Nerial]

Um, Lex hits Clark with a sword in Season 3, episode "Slumber" It was a dream Clark was having.

I seriously doubt the rewind/time loop takes place. I won't say spoilers here, but there's a photo from the Aquaman episode with Clark that seems to confirm no time rewind. It's an official photo, so that wouldn't count as a spoiler, would it? My apologies if it does.

[Chloestheone]

Sorry to break the current discussion, but back to Superchippie's reply, did anyone notice that the largest kryptonite in the rock Clark threw away was heart shaped?

[Crazy4Smallville]

What the WB has ignored or failed to realize is that Clark Kent was the ideal superhero is both morals and powers, not just powers. Yet, they have destroyed the most moralistic traits that he had - Honesty, integrity and purity of heart and mind.

Smallville has made Clark out to be a liar, manipulator and now a fornicator. How can Clark judge Lex on anything Lex does? Lex was right about Clark. He figured out the truth about Clark. Clark has lied to him since the day he met him. Clark has lied to Lana ever since he had known her. Clark has lied to everyone, except his parents - yet he expects everyone to always be honest with him. That also makes him a hypocrite.

Now, he's proven what he truly thinks of Lana. Love isn't about sexual desires - its about intimately sharing your whole being. Two becomes joined together in heart, soul, mind and body as one. Yet, here he has sex with a woman that he's not honest with, can't share a part of himself with (except obviously the physical part). It's not fair to Lana. He has violated her for what? A one-night stand? Once he gets his powers back and can't have sex with her at all, how do you think its going to make her feel? When he can't be honest with her about who he really is - how is she going to feel about the lies he's going to have to keep telling her? If he does become honest with her, how is she going to feel when she realizes that he's responsible for her parents death?

These are not things that Clark doesn't know about. He just refurses to think about them, because he has no self-control. Love is about doing what's best for the person you claim to love. The best thing for Lana - would be for Clark to let her go. But, Clark's not thinking about what's best for her - he's thinking about how he feels and what he wants.

She's not without fault either. She's lying to him and keeping secrets from him, as well. If she truly loved Clark, she would be able to give all of herself to him, but she can't. She too isn't concerned with what's best for Clark - she too has no self-control.

Love is about sacrificing your own desires - and neither were willing to do that for each other. They're both selfish prats who deserve the consequences of their actions. They doomed their relationship, because they have built it on secret, lies and lust.

Lois isn't going to be the cause of their downfall - they are. Lois will just be there to help pick up the pieces.

I'm dissappointed in both Clark and Lana.

I hate that they messed with the canon and mythos, and for what? A few ratings? Too bad TPTB didn't have enough cahunas to stand up and so something right for once.

I'll never expect better of them again! I'll always expect them to be cheesy, sleezy and immoral - because that's all they've ever proven to be.

I'm not angry - I'm just disappointed that they've messed with one of the truly few iconic heroes that we all could have looked up to. They're are not many left.

So, Thank You WB - for destroying something good. You could have at least waited until sweeps week to do it - to at least get something for your efforts. No longer is Clark the greatest superhero - he's just like any other man, with the exception of having a few powers. Though he's alien, he's not above the sins and weaknesses of humanity. He's not alien in nature - he's superhuman. I guess that's what they mean by SuperMan.

[Black cat]

Originally posted by LuckyKrypto
Try being the parent watching it with all of your children. ;)

My 5 year old wants to know "Why is he taking his shirt off?" :eek:

Ditto! I told my 4yr old, "Ugh! Kissing! Don't look or you'll get cooties!" :lol: He thinks girls are gross now anyway so it was effective. It helps that I really did think it was gross! :lol:

Originally posted by Crazy4Smallville
What the WB has ignored or failed to realize is that Clark Kent was the ideal superhero is both morals and powers, not just powers. Yet, they have destroyed the most moralistic traits that he had - Honesty, integrity and purity of heart and mind.

Smallville has made Clark out to be a liar, manipulator and now a fornicator. How can Clark judge Lex on anything Lex does? Lex was right about Clark. He figured out the truth about Clark. Clark has lied to him since the day he met him. Clark has lied to Lana ever since he had known her. Clark has lied to everyone, except his parents - yet he expects everyone to always be honest with him. That also makes him a hypocrite.

Now, he's proven what he truly thinks of Lana. Love isn't about sexual desires - its about intimately sharing your whole being. Two becomes joined together in heart, soul, mind and body as one. Yet, here he has sex with a woman that he's not honest with, can't share a part of himself with (except obviously the physical part). It's not fair to Lana. He has violated her for what? A one-night stand? Once he gets his powers back and can't have sex with her at all, how do you think its going to make her feel? When he can't be honest with her about who he really is - how is she going to feel about the lies he's going to have to keep telling her? If he does become honest with her, how is she going to feel when she realizes that he's responsible for her parents death?

These are not things that Clark doesn't know about. He just refurses to think about them, because he has no self-control. Love is about doing what's best for the person you claim to love. The best thing for Lana - would be for Clark to let her go. But, Clark's not thinking about what's best for her - he's thinking about how he feels and what he wants.

She's not without fault either. She's lying to him and keeping secrets from him, as well. If she truly loved Clark, she would be able to give all of herself to him, but she can't. She too isn't concerned with what's best for Clark - she too has no self-control.

Love is about sacrificing your own desires - and neither were willing to do that for each other. They're both selfish prats who deserve the consequences of their actions. They doomed their relationship, because they have built it on secret, lies and lust.

Lois isn't going to be the cause of their downfall - they are. Lois will just be there to help pick up the pieces.

I'm dissappointed in both Clark and Lana.

I hate that they messed with the canon and mythos, and for what? A few ratings? Too bad TPTB didn't have enough cahunas to stand up and so something right for once.

I'll never expect better of them again! I'll always expect them to be cheesy, sleezy and immoral - because that's all they've ever proven to be.

I'm not angry - I'm just disappointed that they've messed with one of the truly few iconic heroes that we all could have looked up to. They're are not many left.

So, Thank You WB - for destroying something good. You could have at least waited until sweeps week to do it - to at least get something for your efforts. No longer is Clark the greatest superhero - he's just like any other man, with the exception of having a few powers. Though he's alien, he's not above the sins and weaknesses of humanity. He's not alien in nature - he's superhuman. I guess that's what they mean by SuperMan.

Beautifully said.

[fosterco]

geez, lana alway has a bunch of candles lighting up her place. "just in case", i guess. hahaha

[All about Clark]

I'm disappointed with the harshness towards Clark and Lana written above. Clark's learning to this point have only been from humans, why do you expect him to be so far above at this point. Either you've never been in love or are kidding yourself.

It just strikes me that you make all these judgements because they changed the canon. Please learn to deal with it.

[Timester]

Originally posted by All about Clark
I'm disappointed with the harshness towards Clark and Lana written above. Clark's learning to this point have only been from humans, why do you expect him to be so far above at this point. Either you've never been in love or are kidding yourself.

It just strikes me that you make all these judgements because they changed the canon. Please learn to deal with it.

Actually, I agree with Crazy4Smallville. Clark, right now, is nothing more than a dishonest, unethical liar. :\

[Kreukie]

Originally posted by All about Clark
I'm disappointed with the harshness towards Clark and Lana written above. Clark's learning to this point have only been from humans, why do you expect him to be so far above at this point. Either you've never been in love or are kidding yourself.

It just strikes me that you make all these judgements because they changed the canon. Please learn to deal with it.

People are just upset it wasn't Chloe under Clark...or Lois, maybe even Lex. :lol:

[Timester]

Originally posted by Kreukie
People are just upset it wasn't Chloe under Clark...or Lois, maybe even Lex. :lol:

Assumptions, assumptions... :rolleyes:

People are upset because their own reason (morality, ethics, honesty). First, he is still an alien (unless aliens are common on Smallville's Earth, that not normal), second, he tooked Lana's opportunity of choice of doing sex with the real Clark (she doesn't know his secret). Third, he is still lying to her and that will be the crux of Clana again (who are we kidding?). :\

[Kreukie]

It seems the same people who always have an issue with Clana are the ones making an issue about Clark's choices to be with Lana.

[Timester]

Originally posted by Kreukie
It seems the same people who always have an issue with Clana are the ones making an issue about Clark's choices to be with Lana.

Yet, who is defending Lana in this case? I don't like a unethical, dishonest Clark having sex without telling first who he are. He never did that before.

[cxianet]

Originally posted by Kreukie
People are just upset it wasn't Chloe under Clark...or Lois, maybe even Lex. :lol:

I don't really think that's right. All the points that were meant to be made were already made; they weren't honest with each other; Clark wasn't fully himself; all morals just went down the drain. If it was Chloe, Lois, or even Lex under Lex, there would still be an outrage. He just wasn't himself. Clark Kent without his superpowers is like a debator without their evidence; he just wasn't complete.

And the fact that neither of them told each other their secrets didn't exactly help either. Just like to point that out.

I really think Al and Miles messed up big time. If they were going to have Clana sex, at least they'd be smart enough to put in Lois. They took out a lot of Lois and Clois fans with this episode. And the Clois population has been growing. Good job Al and Miles; instead of helping the show you hurt it.

[All about Clark]

Please remember that it was Clark who wanted to take it slow. Lana allowed and agreed that she and Clark could start fresh. And she began pursuing the relationship to the next level.

[babyface14]

they were starting to have it at the end they will probably continue it next week

[cxianet]

Originally posted by All about Clark
Please remember that it was Clark who wanted to take it slow. Lana allowed and agreed that she and Clark could start fresh. And she began pursuing the relationship to the next level.

That's true. However, Clark, being the one with good morals and our superhero that everyone adores and idolizes, should have stopped her from taking that next step. "But she'll dump him!" So? Let her dump him. He knows better than that.

IMO, Clark should have stuck with his original plan and have taken it slow with Lana and never have done the deed.

[RJLCyberPunk]

Originally posted by MBCorp
They were going to have sex. They can't actually show the sex onscreen. And the next episode will probably start with a morning after scene with Clark and Lana lying next to each other in one another's arms.

Do people honestly think they are going to actually show Clark and Lana having sex onscreen on primetime on a comercial network?
What has everyone gone insane?

If people want that better ask the PTB for an unrated version of the episode to be released on the next set of DVDs and that if they ever think is even worth it. I think is not...

[batfinx]

People are just upset it wasn't Chloe under Clark...or Lois, maybe even Lex.

Then you'd be wrong. Chloe isn't even in the myth at all and Lana is a minor character at best. As for Lois, it would only be right after they are adults and considering Clark's current actions, not just his deceitful approach to intimacy, but wanting to shrug off his future, Clark is still just a kid. As for sex with Luthor, I'll put forth the same argument others were making in favor of Clana sex. It's the new millennium, morals are old fashioned. Certainly two consenting adult males could enjoy a night of passion, right? Believe me, I'm not advocating Lex and Clark having sex, but if an argument about "new morality" is made for one pairing, then it should apply to all.

Back on topic, I'm sure Clark and Lana had sex because there is never anything subtle about Smallville. Next week we'll probably get the dew-eyed pillow talk that we didn't get in this episode and that will make it clear that sex occurred. They will be the latest in the WB teen sex scoreboard and nothing more. Even using Clana sex as a ratings ploy failed. Apparently there aren't untold extra millions of Clana fans out there despite what we've been told. Though the fans who wanted Clark to get laid no matter how deceitful the approach, can at least check this one item off their list as accomplished. Congratulations.

Now the deed is done, but we know even without spoilers that Clark's powers will return. Then what? Will he suffer a belated bout of conscience, or will he continue to deceive Lana? I'm guessing the latter.

Please remember that it was Clark who wanted to take it slow. Lana allowed and agreed that she and Clark could start fresh. And she began pursuing the relationship to the next level

And Clark couldn't speak up knowing that Lana's decision was based on her belief that Clark was normal? It all gets back to Clark's decision being self serving. If he was honest with her, she might reject him and then he wouldn't have gotten laid and apparently that's all that matters.

[Dimensio]

Originally posted by MBCorp
They were going to have sex. They can't actually show the sex onscreen.

Tell that to Joss Whedon.

They most certainly can show writhing bodies onscreen, so long as the right things are covered up. I can accept that the producers didn't want complaints about raciness, but they could at least have made the scene a little less of a total cliché. Was the "wind blowing in the curtains" really necessary?!

Originally posted by Veaglarwen
really think they did this scene very tastefully done too. it dispells the idea that sex usually doesn't live up to your hopes and dreams the first time

Yeah...because that's not a realistic notion...

[SmallvilleObsessed]

I myself am a believer of waiting until you're married, so I did frown upon this scene a little. But even so, the scene was very sweet and romantic, and couldn't have been done better. Thankfully they left you to assume what happens, and didn't get all Clana graphic like they did with Alicia and Clark. I must admit I was glad my parents weren't home...!

[LovinMe210]

oh my gosh! i can't read this anymore no i feel really depressed!

...but I loved the episode and I agree with SmallvilleObsessed!

[Lana_Lang #1]

Originally posted by MBCorp
They were going to have sex. They can't actually show the sex onscreen. And the next episode will probably start with a morning after scene with Clark and Lana lying next to each other in one another's arms.

I totally agree hence the part in the trailer when they wake up next to each other and gaze intensely into each others eyes.

I loved everything in this episode and the Clana scenes were straight up TREASURES.

Clark's on top of Lana and then it pans up to the stars.

VERY Nicely done. Letting you know what happened without SEEING it. Applause to TPTB!

Kinda reminded me of a slower more intimate version of the flashback of Joe and Louise doing the deed in the barn.

Also and I can't believe I didn't mention this earlier, THERE WAS CONTINUITY!

They mentioned Pete, Alicia, Jason, Level 3 and the spaceship!!!

This episode was purely a dream come true!

[chlana_sandwich]

I'm not at all convinced that they did it yet. All we saw was some foreplay. Probably, they will continue the scene next week and then we'll know. For all we know, Clark and Lana may reveal their secrets, then do it anyway.

As for the moral issue... while being married first is nice, it's not typical. Clearly, these two have loved each other for a long time. If any two people should be together, it's these two. Of course, we all know that Clark ends up with Lois, but Smallville has always taken some editorial license with the canon. Also, they are both over 18 by now (read: adults). Probably, the producers intended to wait until they became adults before addressing this issue. I think that shows restraint on their parts.

[G'Nort]

Originally posted by Kreukie
They will soon enough! We still have that scene of Clark and Lana naked in bed to look forward to. :D

Dude, look at those pictures more closely. She is wearing a skin colored shirt. You can see the pattern.

I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I don't think they did it. I think that because if they did it would have been written into Birthright. DC is trying to bring its continuity together. They didn't do it.

[Lana_Lang #1]

Clark's on top of Lana and then it pans up to the stars.

Hence the part in the trailer for next week, when they wake up next to each other and gaze intensely into each others eyes.

They did it! It wasn't shown but it was strongly explicit!

[superwannabuffy]

Well I am happy they had sex. Its about time. There are just following all the other WB couples like Dawson and Joey and Buffy and Angel.

[G'Nort]

If they were to do it i promise it would not be "implied" in any way. It would be explicitly stated. How many times do you people have to be strung along to start to notice when it happens?

[shy175223]

Originally posted by G'Nort
Dude, look at those pictures more closely. She is wearing a skin colored shirt. You can see the pattern.

I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I don't think they did it. I think that because if they did it would have been written into Birthright. DC is trying to bring its continuity together. They didn't do it.

Look if Almiles says they did it, they did the deed. they just could not show it in national television . It will be quite obvious in Hidden when the morning after scene.

[G'Nort]

Can someone tell me where Almiles said that? if they did, fine, but I think its a stupid move and I haven't seen that quote.

[LoisNClark]

if you go to the interviews section you can read al gough's interview where he mentions that clark and lana will do the deed so they most likely did it in mortal

[ProudPenny]

It was a fade to black moment. They definitely had sex.

[~*Lois & Clark Fan*~]

Originally posted by shy175223
Look if Almiles says they did it, they did the deed. they just could not show it in national television . It will be quite obvious in Hidden when the morning after scene.

Al and Miles not the most trustworthy sources, just like they said Jason wouldn't be evil too ;)

I really don't care anymore if they did it or not, cause I know it doesn't last, and that will be their downfall eventually

[Dimensio]

Originally posted by Lana_Lang #1
I totally agree hence the part in the trailer when they wake up next to each other and gaze intensely into each others eyes.


"You think maybe next time we can have sex instead of just smoking cigarettes in bed?"

Originally posted by G'Nort
If they were to do it i promise it would not be "implied" in any way. It would be explicitly stated. How many times do you people have to be strung along to start to notice when it happens?

I'm having flashbacks to "Willow and Tara aren't really lesbian lovers!"

[shy175223]

Originally posted by ~*Lois & Clark Fan*~
Al and Miles not the most trustworthy sources, just like they said Jason wouldn't be evil too ;)

I kind of thought that too, in fact ppl kept saying that samething, Almiles do not' trust anything they say. i was kind of hoping of all hope that the clana sex wouldnot happen . that 's what probably kept my hopes about the entire situation:) But it happen. Hey maybe, the rewind thing could happen even though it may be too farfetched.:p

[AnimeJoe]

People are just upset it wasn't Chloe under Clark...or Lois, maybe even Lex.

LOLOL...

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:


I just LOVE some of the man-hating going on in this thread, it totally cracks me up! Of course they won't attack Lana, the FEMALE who pursued it, they'll attack Clark, the MALE for going allong with it even though he loves the girl to death.... TOO funny :lol

Like the old saying goes: "Whatever helps you sleep at night" ;) :p

[Timester]

Originally posted by AnimeJoe
LOLOL...

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:


I just LOVE some of the man-hating going on in this thread, it totally cracks me up! Of course they won't attack Lana, the FEMALE who pursued it, they'll attack Clark, the MALE for going allong with it even though he loves the girl to death.... TOO funny :lol

Like the old saying goes: "Whatever helps you sleep at night" ;) :p

The male has free will and isn't being honest with the female. For example, if a woman wants to have sex with someone married and she doesn't know, is it her fault? :\

[clarksgirl]

OMG did they really do it! lol im sooooo mad i missed this episode! i have to go to a dam drivers ed class that lasts to 730 and it comes on at 7 where i live.... im ssssssssoooo mad im gona miss the whole 5th season... im accually crying! dam stupid driving class god its not that complicated to last for 2 mounths!

[AnimeJoe]

Clark isn't married nor is he involved with anyone else :p..

And Lana has her own secret that she's not being open and honest about.

[cxianet]

Originally posted by AnimeJoe
I just LOVE some of the man-hating going on in this thread, it totally cracks me up! Of course they won't attack Lana, the FEMALE who pursued it, they'll attack Clark, the MALE for going allong with it even though he loves the girl to death.... TOO funny :lol

Like the old saying goes: "Whatever helps you sleep at night" ;) :p

No one's attacking Lana mainly because she's not Superman and she isn't going to grow up and be the superhero that we all know and love and idolize. No, she's just Clark Kent's highschool sweetheart; that's all she is.

And we're not hating on Lana mostly because there's enough Lana-hating already. All the points to be made about her have already been made in other boards.

[batfinx]

I just LOVE some of the man-hating going on in this thread, it totally cracks me up! Of course they won't attack Lana, the FEMALE who pursued it, they'll attack Clark, the MALE for going allong with it even though he loves the girl to death.... TOO funny

If it makes you feel better, I think Lana sometimes comes across as absolutely schizoid in her decision making process. She hadn't even officially broken up with Jason when she went running back to Clark. Her issue with Jason was his secrets and lies, yet went back to Clark, who was famous for his secrets and lies and a guy she had told "the only one who keeps hurting me is you." After she rebounded to Clark she wanted to have sex with him and I don't know if she aggressively approached that because Jason turned her down and now she feels sexually insecure or what. How long had she felt that stone was meant for Clark before she handed it over once it was a blood-covered murder weapon? I think she wanted to start fresh with Clark because it served her own purposes in the secrets and lies department. Feel better? ;)

[slave2moonlight]

Originally posted by All about Clark
I'm disappointed with the harshness towards Clark and Lana written above. Clark's learning to this point have only been from humans, why do you expect him to be so far above at this point. Either you've never been in love or are kidding yourself.

It just strikes me that you make all these judgements because they changed the canon. Please learn to deal with it.

If I have been able to resist several tempting sexual opportunities over my 30 yrs in the hopes of finding Miss Right and marrying her first (and I have a serious libido), you can't imagine my disappointment that Superman couldn't. While Smallville remains my favorite show (there is a lot to like about it AND the characters, let's not be overly harsh), I am very disappointed in the attempt to update Superman for a modern audience simply by demoralizing him.

[Superdan13]

[i]
I'm having flashbacks to "Willow and Tara aren't really lesbian lovers!" [/B]

yes they are.

The line that stood out for me in this show was

"I want my first time to be as special as you are" how nice was that?

[gloria]

Originally posted by Crazy4Smallville
What the WB has ignored or failed to realize is that Clark Kent was the ideal superhero is both morals and powers, not just powers. Yet, they have destroyed the most moralistic traits that he had - Honesty, integrity and purity of heart and mind.

Smallville has made Clark out to be a liar, manipulator and now a fornicator. How can Clark judge Lex on anything Lex does? Lex was right about Clark. He figured out the truth about Clark. Clark has lied to him since the day he met him. Clark has lied to Lana ever since he had known her. Clark has lied to everyone, except his parents - yet he expects everyone to always be honest with him. That also makes him a hypocrite.

Now, he's proven what he truly thinks of Lana. Love isn't about sexual desires - its about intimately sharing your whole being. Two becomes joined together in heart, soul, mind and body as one. Yet, here he has sex with a woman that he's not honest with, can't share a part of himself with (except obviously the physical part). It's not fair to Lana. He has violated her for what? A one-night stand? Once he gets his powers back and can't have sex with her at all, how do you think its going to make her feel? When he can't be honest with her about who he really is - how is she going to feel about the lies he's going to have to keep telling her? If he does become honest with her, how is she going to feel when she realizes that he's responsible for her parents death?

These are not things that Clark doesn't know about. He just refurses to think about them, because he has no self-control. Love is about doing what's best for the person you claim to love. The best thing for Lana - would be for Clark to let her go. But, Clark's not thinking about what's best for her - he's thinking about how he feels and what he wants.

She's not without fault either. She's lying to him and keeping secrets from him, as well. If she truly loved Clark, she would be able to give all of herself to him, but she can't. She too isn't concerned with what's best for Clark - she too has no self-control.

Love is about sacrificing your own desires - and neither were willing to do that for each other. They're both selfish prats who deserve the consequences of their actions. They doomed their relationship, because they have built it on secret, lies and lust.

Lois isn't going to be the cause of their downfall - they are. Lois will just be there to help pick up the pieces.

I'm dissappointed in both Clark and Lana.

I hate that they messed with the canon and mythos, and for what? A few ratings? Too bad TPTB didn't have enough cahunas to stand up and so something right for once.

I'll never expect better of them again! I'll always expect them to be cheesy, sleezy and immoral - because that's all they've ever proven to be.

I'm not angry - I'm just disappointed that they've messed with one of the truly few iconic heroes that we all could have looked up to. They're are not many left.

So, Thank You WB - for destroying something good. You could have at least waited until sweeps week to do it - to at least get something for your efforts. No longer is Clark the greatest superhero - he's just like any other man, with the exception of having a few powers. Though he's alien, he's not above the sins and weaknesses of humanity. He's not alien in nature - he's superhuman. I guess that's what they mean by SuperMan.

OMG!! :eek:
your right!! :eek:
well ive said this before on another thread but i think they had sex too soon in the season..its like all of a sudden they have hormones and need to have sex....they couldve have easily done it after BLANK

this is so depressing..i love CLANA...but your right :eek: :(
i want them to get married and stuff ... :\

[RedQ]

Clark's struggles and necessary personal secrets.STORY WISE: Did he do it or NOT is Still unknown?
IF he did what acceptable reasoning would that be? cause doing it to be normal IS an EXTREAMELY Lame excuse, even in this Culture.Originally posted by lzpoof
Most people started watching this show and got excited about it because it was an opportunity to see what Superman may have been like as a teenager without the weight of the world on his shoulders and without supreme confidence in his abilities.... to enjoy the humor in him discovering himself and abilities and chuckle as he balances homework and meteor freaks...
Yeah the episode didn't do justice like 4.19 Blank. There should have been the same quality of Clark interaction when he does not have his powers. like Perosanl strugles of not being able to save some one cause he has no power and people dying, also Helping someone and he gets hurt BADLY, and Possible pregnancy! (SUPERBOY!), etc...

I'm still hoping for a twist like Lois dies and Chloe takes her identity. (NOT that I don't like ED.)

I wonder if the story twist is:
Lana = Lust
Lois = Love?

Now Chloe had relations with Jimmy Olson that is supposedly a younger Generation. SO Chloe is a cradle-robber.

and in Smallville, Lois is a year Older than Clark.

[foldinglaundry]

I can see why it happened. Clark has always been in love/lust for Lana and Lana falls for guys easily.

They said something about not knowing about tomorrow, so maybe he changed his mind about taking it slow.

Also Clark is not Superman, yet so he can make mistakes.

[love clana]

I think it was great .I whis they would have showed the sex part but i know they couldnt.

[clana_never_give_up]

If they would have shown it then it wouldn't be PG-13 but they could have shown more

[supergirl28]

I'm glad Clark got Lana before Lex. the show is PG-13, they can't show any real hooking up, even though you can see how it ends.